Haunted Hayride Hookups — Bonus Scene

Content Warning: This bonus scene contains explicit FFF sexual content. Intended for readers 18+ who have finished Haunted Hayride Hookups. Contains spoilers.

Still Life

Seven months after. May.

Mars had a problem.

The problem was not the painting. The painting was going well — better than well, actually, the kind of effortless flow state where her hand seemed to move independent of conscious thought and the colors bloomed on the canvas with the authority of something that had always existed and was merely allowing itself to be seen. She’d been working since dawn, which was unusual even for her raccoon-schedule creative process, and the light in the garage studio was perfect: warm and golden, slanting through the window Jo had installed last week, catching the dust motes that perpetually drifted through the space like tiny, paint-flecked constellations.

The problem was the reference material.

Specifically: the problem was that she’d been trying to paint a figure study from a photograph she’d taken of Tessa and Jo last Sunday — the two of them on the porch, Tessa leaning against Jo’s shoulder, Jo’s arm around her waist, both of them backlit by the kind of golden-hour light that made Mars’s artistic brain short-circuit — and the longer she stared at the photograph, the less interested she became in translating it to canvas and the more interested she became in going inside and putting her hands on both of them.

This was a recurring issue.

Living with the two most beautiful women in Briar Glen — in Michigan — in the observable universe, Mars’s internal hierarchy was not subtle — meant that inspiration and arousal had become functionally indistinguishable. She’d tried to explain this to Tessa once. Tessa had told her that conflating aesthetic appreciation with sexual desire was not a legitimate artistic philosophy. Mars had pointed out that the entire Italian Renaissance would disagree, and Tessa had kissed her to shut her up, which had only proven Mars’s point.

She set down her brush. Wiped her hands on the rag that lived on her thigh like a permanent accessory. Looked at the photograph one more time.

Jo’s forearm. The tendons visible beneath the skin, the fine dark hair, the way her hand splayed across Tessa’s hip with the casual possessiveness of a woman who touched what she loved without thinking about it. And Tessa — Tessa’s throat, the line of it, the way her head tilted back against Jo’s shoulder in a posture of absolute, unguarded trust that Tessa Monroe granted to approximately two people on the entire planet.

“Fuck it,” Mars said to the empty studio, and went inside.

She found them in the living room.

A Saturday in May. Late morning. The farmhouse was quiet in the particular way it got on weekends when there was no event to run and no crisis to manage and the three of them existed in the rare, luxurious space of having nothing they had to do. Jo was on the couch reading a repair manual — not for any machine in particular, just recreationally, because Jo Navarro’s idea of leisure reading was a Kubota service manual and Mars had learned not to judge. Tessa was on the floor with her laptop, spreadsheet open, but her typing had slowed to the intermittent, unfocused rhythm that meant her attention was drifting.

They both looked up when Mars appeared in the doorway.

“I need you,” Mars said.

Jo closed the manual. Tessa closed the laptop.

That was the thing about them — about all three of them, really, about the particular chemistry of this specific triad. They’d learned to read each other’s frequencies. And the frequency Mars was broadcasting right now was not the I need help moving a canvas frequency or the I need someone to taste this sauce frequency. It was the other one. The one that made the air between them change temperature.

“Both of you,” Mars added, as if clarification were necessary. “In my studio.”

“Why the studio?” Tessa asked. The question was practical, not resistant. Tessa Monroe did not resist. Tessa Monroe assessed terrain.

“Because I want to draw you.” Mars leaned against the doorframe. “Together. On the drop cloth. In the light.”

A pause. Jo looked at Tessa. Tessa looked at Mars.

“Draw us,” Tessa repeated.

“Figure study.”

“You want us to model.”

“I want you to take your clothes off and lie down together on the canvas tarp in my studio while I sketch you, and then I want to see what happens after that.”

“You already know what happens after that,” Jo said. Her voice had dropped into the low register — the one that meant her body had already made a decision her mouth was catching up to.

“I have theories,” Mars said. “I’d like to test them.”

The studio smelled like turpentine and linseed oil and the ghost of cedar from the lumber Jo stored along the far wall. Mars had dragged the drop cloth — a paint-splattered canvas tarp that had served as the floor of her workspace for three months — into the center of the room, into the pool of light from the new window. She grabbed two cushions from the stack in the corner and tossed them onto the tarp.

Jo stood at the edge, already unbuttoning her flannel with the methodical calm that made Mars’s heartbeat stumble every single time. Buttons one, two, three, four. The flannel dropped. Underneath: a white tank top that clung to her chest and shoulders and the flat plane of her stomach, and Mars wanted to put her mouth on every inch of visible skin but that wasn’t the plan — the plan was the sketch, the figure study, the artistic exercise that would inevitably become something else, and the becoming was part of the art.

Tessa was watching Mars. Evaluating. The particular expression that meant she was deciding whether to surrender control or negotiate terms.

“Rules?” Tessa asked.

“No rules. Just… lie down. Be together. Let me look at you.”

Tessa pulled her shirt over her head. No bra — a Saturday morning decision that Mars silently, fervently appreciated. Her breasts were full and dark-nippled and Mars’s fingers twitched toward her pencil.

Jo’s tank top came off next. Then her jeans. Then everything else, with the efficient unselfconsciousness of a woman who had never been precious about her own body because her body was a tool she’d used for hard labor her entire life and she’d learned — was still learning, with their help — that it could also be a source of pleasure. Jo was lean and strong, broad-shouldered, her skin darker than Tessa’s against the pale canvas of the tarp. The surgery scars on her chest were smooth and flat, five years healed, and Mars’s gaze moved over them the way it moved over everything about Jo: with attention, appreciation, desire, and the bone-deep knowledge that every part of this woman was exactly right.

Tessa undressed with more deliberation. She folded her clothes. She set them aside. She stood naked in the shaft of light, and Mars watched the way the gold caught in the brown of her skin, the round softness of her thighs, the curve of her waist, the dark curls between her legs.

“Lie down,” Mars said. Her voice came out rougher than she intended.

They did. Jo on her back, one arm behind her head, her body a study in angular lines and lean muscle. Tessa curled against her, one leg over Jo’s thigh, her hand flat on Jo’s chest, her face turned toward Mars with an expression that was half challenge and half invitation.

Mars sat on the stool. Opened her sketchbook. Started to draw.

For three minutes, she was an artist.

She captured the line of Jo’s collarbone. The weight of Tessa’s breast against Jo’s ribs. The way their legs intertwined, dark and darker against the paint-spotted canvas. The negative space between Tessa’s throat and Jo’s jaw. The light.

Then Tessa shifted. Her hand slid from Jo’s chest to her stomach. Her fingertips traced the ridge of muscle below Jo’s navel, and Jo’s breath changed — not dramatically, just a slight catch, a tightening of her abs under Tessa’s touch — and Mars’s pencil stopped.

“Don’t stop on my account,” Tessa murmured. She wasn’t looking at Mars anymore. She was looking at her own hand on Jo’s skin. Her fingers drifted lower. Just slightly. Just enough.

Jo’s hips tilted. A millimeter. An involuntary response that she would have controlled six months ago and now allowed because she’d learned that allowing was not the same as losing.

“Tessa.” Mars’s voice. Warning, or permission, or both.

“You said no rules.” Tessa’s hand flattened against Jo’s lower belly. She could feel Jo’s muscles tighten beneath her palm. “You said be together. Let you look.”

“I said — yes. I said that.”

“Then look.”

Tessa’s fingers slid between Jo’s thighs.

Mars stopped pretending to draw.

Jo’s response was immediate and unhidden — a full-body shudder, her head pressing back into the cushion, her hips rising against Tessa’s hand. Tessa knew her. Knew exactly where to touch, exactly how much pressure, exactly the slow circling rhythm that unwound Jo Navarro from the core. Her fingers moved with confident precision, and Jo’s hand came up to grip Tessa’s thigh where it crossed her own — not directing, just holding on.

“Mars.” Jo’s voice. Low. Strained. Her eyes were open and she was looking straight at Mars across the studio with the raw, unguarded expression of a woman being touched exactly right and wanting to be seen while it happened. “Get over here.”

Mars was off the stool before the sentence finished.

She crossed the studio in four steps. Knelt on the tarp between their legs. The canvas was rough under her knees and she didn’t care — didn’t care about anything except the sight of Tessa’s hand between Jo’s legs and the sounds Jo was making and the almost painful ache between her own thighs that demanded attention.

“Let me,” Mars said, and put her mouth on Jo’s inner thigh.

Jo’s hips jerked. Mars felt the movement against her lips — the tremor of muscle, the heat of skin that was already flushed and sensitive. She kissed upward. Slowly. Deliberately. Giving Tessa’s hand room to work while she tasted the salt-clean skin of Jo’s thigh, the crease where thigh met hip, the impossible softness there.

“Together,” Jo breathed. “Both of you. I want—”

She didn’t finish. She didn’t need to. Tessa’s fingers shifted, spreading Jo open, making space, and Mars lowered her mouth.

The sound Jo made was guttural and broken and perfect.

Mars worked with her tongue — slow, flat strokes at first, tasting, learning the rhythm of what made Jo shake. Tessa’s fingers were right there, slick and insistent, and they found a tandem without speaking: Tessa’s fingers inside, curling, pressing; Mars’s tongue on Jo’s clit, circling, flicking, sealing her lips around the swollen bud and sucking gently while Jo’s entire body arched off the drop cloth.

Jo’s hand fisted in Mars’s hair. Not pulling — anchoring. Her other hand gripped Tessa’s wrist, holding Tessa’s hand exactly where it was, and the sound of Jo Navarro lost in pleasure filled the garage studio like music.

Mars pulled back just enough to breathe. “Look at me, Jo.”

Jo looked. Her eyes were dark and glazed, her chest heaving, her lips bitten red. She looked at Mars with an expression of desperate, furious, grateful need, and Mars held eye contact and lowered her mouth again and pressed her tongue flat and hard against Jo’s clit while Tessa’s fingers curled deeper, and Jo came.

Not quiet. Not controlled. A ragged cry that rattled the jars of paint on Mars’s shelves, her hips bucking against Mars’s mouth, her thighs clamping around Mars’s head, Tessa’s name and Mars’s name tangled together in a sound that was closer to a sob than a word.

Mars stayed with her through it. Gentled her tongue as the aftershocks rolled through, kissing softly where she’d sucked hard, feeling Jo’s grip in her hair loosen from desperate to tender.

Then Tessa’s hand was in Mars’s hair too, pulling her up, pulling her close, and Tessa kissed her with Jo’s taste still on her lips and Mars groaned into Tessa’s mouth because she was so turned on she couldn’t think straight and the kiss was filthy and deep and Tessa’s tongue chased every trace of Jo from Mars’s mouth like a woman claiming territory.

“Your turn,” Tessa murmured against Mars’s lips.

“I can’t — I’m going to — if you touch me I’ll last about thirty seconds.”

“Fifteen,” Jo said from the floor, her voice wrecked, her hand already reaching for Mars’s waistband. “I give you fifteen.”

Mars was still wearing her painting clothes — a tank top and cutoffs, no underwear because she’d stopped wearing underwear to paint three weeks ago when Jo had walked into the studio and pressed her against the workbench and she’d learned that fabric was just an obstacle. Jo’s hands found the button on the cutoffs. Popped it. Dragged the zipper down with the focused efficiency of a woman who was still trembling from her own orgasm but whose hands never fumbled when it mattered.

The cutoffs hit the tarp. Mars’s tank top followed. And then she was naked on the paint-splattered canvas between the two women she loved, the light from the window warm on her skin, and Jo’s hands were on her hips pulling her down and Tessa was behind her, kneeling, her breasts pressed against Mars’s back, her mouth on Mars’s neck.

“Lie back,” Jo said.

Mars lay back. The drop cloth was rough and warm beneath her and she could feel the texture of dried paint under her shoulder blades and she stared up at the garage ceiling — the track lighting she’d installed, the exposed beams, the cobweb in the corner she kept meaning to clean — and then she couldn’t see anything at all because Tessa’s hand was over her eyes.

“Don’t look,” Tessa said. “Feel.”

Mars whimpered. The loss of sight sharpened everything else — the rasp of the canvas against her bare skin, the cool air from the window on her nipples, Jo’s breath against her inner thigh as she settled between Mars’s legs.

“Please,” Mars said, because she was not too proud to beg and because begging was its own kind of art and because she’d been wet since she walked out of this studio twenty minutes ago and she was going to lose her mind if someone didn’t touch her in the next—

Jo’s mouth.

Not teasing. Not gradual. Jo went in like she did everything — with purpose and commitment and the kind of focused intensity that made Mars see stars behind Tessa’s hand. Her tongue was hot and direct, finding Mars’s clit immediately, working it with firm, rhythmic strokes that told Mars that Jo had been paying very close attention to what Mars’s body liked and had catalogued every response with the thoroughness of a woman who maintained machines for a living.

“Oh fuck — Jo — fuck—”

Tessa’s hand stayed over her eyes. Her other hand found Mars’s breast, rolling her nipple between her fingers, and Mars arched into both sensations at once — Tessa’s hand and Jo’s mouth and the overwhelming, blinding pleasure of being worked over by two women who knew her body like a blueprint.

Jo added her fingers. Two, sliding in slow, curling forward, finding the spot that made Mars’s vision go white even behind the darkness of Tessa’s palm. She fucked Mars with the same unhurried thoroughness she brought to everything, her mouth never leaving Mars’s clit, and Mars was making sounds that she would have been embarrassed about if she had any capacity left for embarrassment, which she did not, because Jo’s fingers were hitting exactly the right angle and Tessa was pinching her nipple and whispering in her ear—

“You’re so wet. I can hear it. I can hear what Jo’s doing to you. Can you hear it, Mars?”

She could. The obscene, slick sound of Jo’s fingers inside her, the wet press of Jo’s mouth, her own ragged breathing — the acoustics of the garage made everything louder, rawer, more present. Every sound bounced off the concrete and the bare walls and came back amplified.

“Tell me when you’re close,” Tessa said.

“I’m close — I was close before she — oh god — I’m—”

Tessa took her hand away from Mars’s eyes.

The light hit her. The golden, window-filtered light of the studio, and through the glare she saw Jo between her legs — Jo’s dark eyes looking up at her over the terrain of her own body, Jo’s mouth glistening, Jo’s fingers buried inside her — and she saw Tessa beside her, flushed and bare and beautiful, watching Mars fall apart with an expression of such fierce, possessive tenderness that Mars felt it crack something open inside her chest.

She came so hard she screamed.

Not a curated theatrical sound. A raw, ripped-out, full-throttle scream that startled a bird off the garage windowsill and probably carried across the field and into the neighboring county. Jo held her through it — fingers pressing deep, mouth gentling but not stopping, drawing out every last spasm until Mars was shaking and gasping and laughing and crying simultaneously, which was an emotional state she had not previously known was possible but which felt, in this moment, like the only honest response.

“Fifteen seconds,” Jo said, lifting her head. Her mouth curved. “I was generous.”

“You were — that was — I can’t feel my legs.”

“Good.” Jo kissed Mars’s thigh. Gentle. A period at the end of a sentence.

“Tessa,” Mars managed. “Tessa hasn’t—”

“I know,” Tessa said. She was already moving. Already positioning herself. “I’ve been watching both of you and I know exactly what I want.”

She straddled Mars’s thigh.

Mars felt it — the slick heat of Tessa’s arousal against her skin, the weight of her settling, the flex of her hips as she found her angle. Tessa braced her hands on Mars’s shoulders and started to move — riding Mars’s thigh with a slow, grinding roll that pressed her clit against the firm muscle, and Mars could feel how wet she was, could feel the evidence of exactly how turned on Tessa had gotten from watching and touching and orchestrating.

“Jo,” Tessa said. Commanding. The voice she used when she’d decided what she wanted and was done negotiating. “Behind me.”

Jo moved into position. Kneeling behind Tessa, her chest against Tessa’s back, her hands sliding around to cup Tessa’s breasts. She rolled Tessa’s nipples between her fingers and Tessa’s hips stuttered, her grinding faltering as sensation multiplied.

Mars put her hands on Tessa’s hips. Guided the rhythm. Pressed her thigh up harder, giving Tessa more friction, more pressure, and Tessa took it — rode it — her head falling back against Jo’s shoulder, her mouth open, her eyes half-closed.

“Harder,” Tessa breathed.

Mars gripped tighter. Lifted her thigh higher. Tessa ground down with increasing urgency, her movements losing their controlled rhythm, becoming desperate and honest and raw.

Jo’s hand slid down Tessa’s stomach. Down between her legs, finding her clit from behind while Tessa rode Mars’s thigh, and the double stimulation — Mars’s thigh against her opening, Jo’s fingers on her clit — made Tessa cry out in a voice Mars had never heard from her before. High and broken and free.

“That’s it,” Mars whispered, watching Tessa’s face, memorizing every expression, every micro-shift of pleasure across her features. “That’s it, baby. Take what you need.”

Tessa’s orgasm hit her like a wave. Her whole body seized — hands clenching on Mars’s shoulders hard enough to leave marks, thighs clamping around Mars’s leg, her hips jerking in sharp, helpless thrusts as Jo’s fingers kept working and Mars’s hands held her steady through the shaking.

She collapsed forward onto Mars’s chest. Panting. Trembling. Jo draped over both of them, her weight a warm blanket, her breath hot against the back of Tessa’s neck.

Three women on a paint-stained drop cloth in a garage studio in rural Michigan. Naked, sweating, tangled together in the late-morning light, surrounded by canvases and paint jars and the ghost of turpentine.

Mars stared at the ceiling. Her heart was hammering. Her body was still buzzing. She had paint on her knee — cobalt blue, she noticed, from a dried splatter on the tarp — and Tessa had a smear of cadmium yellow on her shoulder blade from where she’d pressed against a palette Mars had left on the floor.

“I’m going to paint this,” Mars murmured.

“You are not painting this,” Tessa said into Mars’s collarbone.

“I’m going to paint this. Not literally — not pornographically. Just… the light. The shapes. The way you two look right now, all tangled up. It would be—”

“No.”

“It would be art.“

“Absolutely not.”

“Tessa. I can see the composition. The light is perfect. The colors — your skin against the tarp, Jo’s hands, the way the shadows—”

“Mars.”

“Abstract. I’d make it abstract. Nobody would know.”

“I would know.”

“You would know you’re the subject of a beautiful abstract painting hanging in our living room that only the three of us could decode. That’s romantic.”

Tessa lifted her head. Looked at Mars with the particular expression of a woman who had just been fucked senseless and was already regaining her operational faculties. “Jo?”

“Hmm,” Jo said. She hadn’t moved. Her eyes were closed. Her hand was tracing lazy circles on Tessa’s hip.

“Mars wants to paint our sex life and hang it in the living room.”

“Abstract,” Mars clarified.

“Heard you the first time.” Jo’s mouth twitched. The almost-smile. “Do it.”

“Jo!”

“It’s a compliment,” Jo said. “She thinks we’re art.”

“We are art,” Mars agreed.

“We are three women on a dirty tarp in a garage,” Tessa said, but she was smiling — the private smile, the one Mars had spent seven months earning and would spend the rest of her life collecting — and she laid her head back on Mars’s chest and didn’t say no again.

Outside, the May sun climbed higher over the field. Somewhere, a bird resettled on the windowsill it had been startled from. The coffee Mars had made that morning — incorrectly, as always — sat cold and forgotten on Jo’s backup toolbox.

They would get up eventually. They would shower — in shifts, because the curtain rod incident remained a structural concern — and Mars would start the painting and Tessa would reclaim her spreadsheet and Jo would fix something that didn’t need fixing because that was how Jo loved: by maintaining, by tending, by keeping the things around her in working order so the people she loved never had to worry about the infrastructure of their life.

But that was later. Right now, in the golden light of the studio, they stayed.

Mars reached for her sketchbook. Drew a single line — the curve of Tessa’s spine, the slope of Jo’s shoulder, the place where all three of them converged — and called it done.

It was, she thought, the best thing she’d ever drawn.

Loved This Scene?

Read the full book — Tessa, Mars, and Jo’s complete story from first spark to HEA.

Read Free on Kindle Unlimited

Haunted Hayride Hookups — Bonus Scene

Still Life

Loved This Scene?

More from Isla Wilde

Stay in the Loop

Be first to know when Isla Wilde publishes

Thank you for sign up!

Review Cart