
Fake Girlfriend, Real Orgasms
A Sapphic Fake-Dating Romcom
by Riley Kendra

Available at all major retailers
Pairing: FF (Sapphic)
Heat: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Inferno
Tropes: Fake Dating, Strangers to Lovers, Forced Proximity, One Bed, Thin Walls, Big Loud Italian Family, Grandmother Knows Best, Coming Out, Blue-Collar Heroine, Curvy Heroine, Pact with Rules, Lake House Romance, Wedding Romance, Found Family, Dirty Talk, Mutual Pining, Romantic Comedy, Dual POV, HEA
She hired a stranger to be her girlfriend for four days. The walls were thinner than the lie.
Rule one: it’s a performance.
Marnie Castellano has four days, sixty relatives, and one problem: the girlfriend she invented at Christmas doesn’t exist. Then her car dies on Route 14, and the woman at Pump 4, six feet of union electrician who just got dumped by text, has a truck, a free week, and a girlfriend-shaped hole of her own.
Rule two: anything physical is for the audience.
Jess Orlowski needs a date for her brother’s wedding, because she’s done hiding and she’s coming out in front of every Polish Catholic in Cheektowaga. Marnie needs someone to survive Grandma Rosa. They shake on it over slushies. Four days at the lake house, one wedding in return, nobody gets hurt.
Rule three: no real feelings.
Then the family gives “the girlfriend” the good room. The one with one bed. And walls so thin the whole house can hear when two people aren’t having sex, which means they’d better start sounding like they are.
Fake Girlfriend, Real Orgasms is a scorching ~87,000-word sapphic fake-dating romcom with dual POV, strangers to lovers, one bed, a big loud Italian family, a grandmother who knew all along, and a happily ever after said out loud, in front of everybody.
You’ll love this book if you enjoy:
✅ A dead Hyundai named Dolores, a mechanic who says “Part comes Tuesday,” and two slushies: cherry and blue raspberry
✅ A five-rule pact typed into a notes app, and a honeymoon suite with a rose-petal heart that says the wrong initial
✅ A calibration kiss against a B&B door that does not stay calibrated
✅ Paper-thin walls, a sister on the other side, fake sex noises, and “Make it sound real, Mar”
✅ Sauce day, a breaker panel from 1971, and an uncle who weeps holding the flashlight
✅ A storm, a dock nobody can see from the house, and a boathouse with a tin roof
✅ A coming-out speech at a Polish wedding, a mother who raises her glass, and pierogi in a parish-hall kitchen
✅ A grandmother who leaves cannoli under the door with a note: The walls are thin. The love is thick.
✅ 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ heat and an HEA guaranteed
⚠️ Content Warning: This novel contains extremely explicit sexual content (graphic FF scenes throughout, including oral, fingering, thigh-riding, face-sitting, scissoring, a strap-on, masturbation while being talked through it, and sex in a truck), strong language and alcohol. It depicts deceiving a family with a fake relationship, a public exposure and breakup, and coming out to family, including a relative who walks out. Also includes references to the past death of a parent and a grandparent. Intended for readers 18+.
📖 Read Chapter One Free
Not sure yet? Read all of Chapter One right here.
Chapter One
MARNIE
The car started making the noise somewhere south of Geneva, and I did what any emotionally healthy thirty-one-year-old woman would do. I turned up the radio.
Dolores had made noises before. Dolores was a 2012 Hyundai Elantra the color of a Band-Aid, with a cracked cupholder and a personality. She rattled in the cold. She whined on hills. She once, in the parking garage of Buffalo General, played a Michael Bublé CD I have never owned and cannot explain. A noise, with Dolores, was not a crisis. A noise was a conversation.
This noise was a cough. A deep, wet, consumptive cough from somewhere under the hood, like a Victorian orphan in the last chapter of a very sad book.
“No,” I told her. “Absolutely not. Not this weekend. You can die in August like a normal car.”
My phone buzzed in the cupholder. I did not have to look. I looked.
NAME.
Then, half a second later, because my sister has never once sent a single text when four would do:
Marnie I need a NAME.
Aunt Carm is embroidering place cards.
She is sitting on the porch with the thread OUT.
I put the phone face-down on the passenger seat, on top of the binder, which was where I put everything I didn’t want to deal with. The binder was three inches thick and color-tabbed. It contained the seating chart for Saturday’s party, the bocce bracket, a laminated schedule of Nonna’s blood pressure pills, a list of which cousins could not be placed within ten feet of which other cousins, and a section in the back labeled CONTINGENCIES that I had started in June and abandoned in a panic after one page.
It did not contain a girlfriend. That was the problem. That had been the problem since Christmas Eve.
Here is what you have to understand about my family.
There are a lot of us. Not big Irish family a lot, not Mormon cousins a lot — Castellano a lot, which is its own unit of measurement. My grandmother Rosa had six children, and those six had sixteen, and those sixteen have been breeding with the kind of focus usually reserved for endangered pandas. When we gather, we do not fit in rooms. We fit in zip codes.
And we gather constantly. Baptisms, confirmations, graduations, the annual fight about whose turn it is to host Easter, which nobody wins and everybody attends. And at every single one of those gatherings, since the year I turned twenty-two, someone has found me by the dessert table and asked, in a tone of tender devastation, “So. Anybody special?”
The answer was no. The answer was always no. I came out at twenty-four, at Toni’s wedding, by accident — a bridesmaid I’d been flirting with kissed me behind the DJ booth and Aunt Lucia walked in on it holding a tray of sfogliatelle. Lucia looked at us for a long moment, said “Well, finally, something interesting,” and offered us both a pastry. By the end of the night the news had circulated through the entire bloodline, and the response was overwhelming, unanimous, and loud: Wonderful! So when’s she coming to Sunday dinner?
My family never cared that I liked women. My family cared that I never brought one home.
Seven years of that. Seven years of being set up with the granddaughter of a woman from Nonna’s church, the hygienist at my cousin’s dentist, a lesbian my uncle Sal met at a gas station, which in hindsight should have been a warning. Seven years of being introduced to people as our Marnie, she’s still figuring it out, as if I were a puzzle missing a corner piece. Seven years at the kids’ table of life, while Toni got married, bought a house in Clarence, had Gianna, had Leo, perfected a cassata so beautiful it once made a priest cry, and became, in every way the family could measure, the daughter who’d done it right.
I love my sister. I want to be very clear about that. I would take a bullet for my sister.
I’d just prefer she didn’t load it.
So: Christmas Eve. Nonna’s house in North Buffalo, the Feast of the Seven Fishes, forty people in a dining room built for twelve, card tables extended into the living room, the hallway, the base of the stairs. Nonna at the head of the table, lighting the candles in the brass holders Nonno Vito bought her the year they were married. Everybody quiet for once, because when Rosa Castellano lights candles you shut up and watch.
She’d said, “Next summer I’m eighty.”
We all said things like No! and You don’t look a day over sixty! and Uncle Sal said “Seventy-nine and a half, Ma, don’t rush it,” which got a laugh.
And Nonna smiled her small, private smile and said, “When I blow out my candles, I already know my wish. All my grandbabies, happy. That’s all. Everybody happy. Everybody with somebody.”
She looked down the table when she said it. She looked down the table, past Toni and Paulie, past cousin Danielle and her fiancé, past the twins and their wives — and she looked at me.
And in that exact moment, as if God had written the scene himself for comic timing, my sister stood up, tapped her wineglass with a fork, and announced that she and Paulie were expecting baby number three.
The room exploded. Nonna wept. Paulie got kissed by eleven aunts. Somebody started singing. And in the middle of the noise, while everyone was hugging Toni, Nonna reached over and squeezed my hand. Not hard. Just enough. Her fingers were cool and thin and she smelled like anise and Jean Naté, and she looked at me with so much hope it physically hurt.
My mouth opened. I have thought a lot about what happened next, and I want the record to show that my brain was not consulted.
“I’m seeing someone,” my mouth said.
The room did not go quiet. The room went silent, which in my family is a different and much more dangerous thing. Forty Castellanos turned their heads toward me at once, like a field of very loud sunflowers.
Nonna’s eyes filled. She crossed herself. She put both hands on my face and kissed my forehead, my cheek, my other cheek, and said, “Finalmente. Bring her. Bring her to my birthday. I want to meet her at the lake.”
“Of course,” I heard myself say. “She’d love that.”
Toni was already pulling out her phone. “What’s her name? Do you have a picture? How long? Marnie, oh my God, how long?“
“It’s new,” I said. “It’s — you know. We’re keeping it quiet. She’s private.”
That was seven months ago. I have been paying interest on it ever since.
Dolores coughed again, harder, and something under the hood made a sound like a coffee can full of bolts going down a staircase.
“Okay,” I said. “Okay, okay, okay. We’re fine. Everything’s fine.”
I was on Route 14, on the west side of Seneca Lake, because I’d detoured. Nonna’s eightieth birthday present was in my back seat: a mixed case from Glass Hill Winery, the little vineyard outside Geneva where Nonno Vito took her on their first date in 1963 and asked her to marry him on their fourth. The winery had been sold twice since then, and the new owners had no idea who Vito Castellano was, but the young guy at the counter had been very sweet about it. He’d even let me see the new tasting room — still smelled like sawdust, all blond wood and Edison bulbs. Electricians just finished this afternoon, he told me, flipping a switch so the whole room glowed gold. Pretty, right?
It was pretty. I’d taken a picture of it for Nonna. Then I’d gotten back in Dolores and started the last forty minutes of the drive to the lake house, twenty-four hours ahead of the rest of the family, because I am the one who gets there early. I air out the rooms. I make the beds. I check the propane and fight with the dock lights and tape the seating chart to the inside of the pantry door. I am the Castellano who makes things run, which is a very useful thing to be when you are not the Castellano anyone is proud of.
The plan — and I had a plan, I always have a plan — was to use those twenty-four hours to choose.
I’d been making the list in my notes app for a month. I pulled up at a red light in some town that was mostly a church and a pizza place and looked at it again.
OPTIONS
1. Confess.
2. Breakup. She dumped me. Tragic. Very recent. Can’t talk about it.
3. Produce a human.
Option one was the right answer. I knew it was the right answer. I’d known it for seven months. You stand up at the birthday dinner and you say Nonna, I lied, I’m sorry, I wanted you to be happy, and then you let your family do what your family does, which is yell, cry, forgive, and bring it up at every holiday until somebody dies.
Every time I imagined doing it, my throat closed like a fist.
Option two was cowardly but plausible. The problem with option two was that Toni would want details, and Aunt Dee would want to set me up with someone new by Saturday morning, and Nonna would look at me with those hopeful wet eyes and say Oh, cara, and I would want to walk into the lake.
Option three was not a real option. Option three was on the list because I’m thorough.
The light turned green. Dolores lurched forward, wheezed, and the check-engine light, which had been on since roughly 2019 and which I had come to think of as decorative, began to flash.
“That’s new,” I said.
It was not, in fact, new. It was the last thing she ever did.
I made it to a gas station by the grace of God and momentum. Dolores rolled into the lot of a place called the Gas-N-Go in a town called Dresden, coasted past the air pump, the ice chest, and a hand-painted sign that said NIGHTCRAWLERS — ASK INSIDE, and died next to Pump 3 with a long, final, theatrical sigh.
I sat there with my hands on the wheel.
The Gas-N-Go had four pumps, a picnic table, a two-bay garage with one bay open, and a convenience store with a neon sign that said SLUSH with the H burned out. Across the road, Seneca Lake was blue and flat and glittering under the July sun like it had never had a problem in its life.
My phone buzzed. I didn’t look.
It buzzed again. I looked.
Nonna asked if your girlfriend eats veal.
Does she eat veal?
Marnie does she eat VEAL
I typed She’s vegetarian and then deleted it, because Nonna would make her a separate eggplant parm, by hand, at eighty, and I could not survive that kind of guilt. I typed She eats everything! and deleted that, too, because it sounded like a lie, which it was, about a person who was also a lie.
I put the phone down and went to find a mechanic.
The mechanic’s name was Earl. I know this because it was stitched on his shirt and because he said, when I walked into the open bay, “Earl,” the way some people say hello and other people say what now. He was about seventy, with forearms like hams and a toothpick he moved from one side of his mouth to the other instead of having facial expressions.
He listened to me describe the noise. I did the noise. I did the noise twice, with hand gestures. He walked out to Pump 3, popped Dolores’s hood, looked inside for what I can only describe as a respectful period of mourning, and moved the toothpick.
“Fuel pump,” Earl said.
“Okay. Great. Can you fix it?”
“Can order one.”
“Wonderful. When does it get here?”
He moved the toothpick back. “Part comes Tuesday.”
I laughed. It was not a good laugh. It was a laugh with a hairline crack running all the way through it.
“Tuesday,” I said. “Tuesday. Earl. I have to be at my grandmother’s lake house tonight. My family arrives tomorrow. It’s her eightieth birthday. There’s going to be sixty people. I have the bocce bracket.” I gestured at Dolores’s back seat, where the binder sat beside the wine like a passenger. “I have the bracket, Earl.”
Earl looked at the binder. Earl looked at me. “Tuesday,” he said, with what might have been sympathy and might have been gas. “Could call you a tow.”
“To where?”
“Here.” He thought about it. “It’s already here.”
He went back into the garage. I stood in the sun next to my dead car and did something I’d been doing since I was six years old and Toni locked me in the pantry during hide-and-seek: I opened the list.
OPTIONS
1. Confess.
2. Breakup.
3. Produce a human.
4. Uber?? (Dresden?? Is that a real place??)
5. Fake my own death
I was adding a sixth option, which was just the word lake, when I noticed the woman at Pump 4.
I want to describe this accurately, because later it became important to establish a timeline.
She was standing beside a black pickup truck — older, dusty, a Chevy, with a ladder rack on top and mud on the wheel wells — and she was swearing at her phone. Not loudly. Not dramatically. With a kind of low, steady, workmanlike fluency, as if swearing were a trade she’d apprenticed in.
She was tall. That was the first thing. Taller than me by a lot, which isn’t hard, but taller than most people, with long legs in work jeans gone soft and pale at the knees. She had on a flannel shirt in July — red and black, sleeves shoved up past the elbow — and under it a white tank top that had been through the wash so many times it had given up on opacity. Her hair was dark, buzzed close at the sides and longer on top, pushed back off her forehead like she’d done it with her hand and her hand had done a better job than any stylist I’ve ever paid.
The forearms. I need to talk about the forearms.
I am a professional woman. I work in hospital billing. I have a 401(k) and a standing appointment with a dental hygienist and a throw pillow on my couch that says LIVE LAUGH LASAGNA, which was a gift and which I display ironically, mostly. I am not a person who gets stopped in her tracks by a forearm.
These forearms were long and roped and tan, with veins running down them like somebody had drawn the map to somewhere I wanted to go. There was a scar on the left one, a shiny burn about the size of a playing card, and while I watched she rubbed her thumb over it absently, the way you’d touch something you’d stopped noticing years ago. Her hands were big. Square-knuckled. The kind of hands that looked like they’d know what to do with anything you put in them.
My brain, which had been at a rolling boil of panic for most of the afternoon, went very quiet and very specific. It said: oh.
Then she looked up from the phone and her face did something that made the rest of my brain go quiet too.
She had the kind of jaw that makes aunts lose their place in a sentence. Hard, clean, a line you could cut glass with. A straight nose. Dark eyes under straight dark brows, and they were furious — not at me, at the phone, at the world — and then she exhaled and the fury just went, folded up and put away like a tool back in a belt. What was left was tired. Tired and a little wry, like she’d just been told a joke at her own expense and had to admit it was a good one.
She shoved the phone in her back pocket, braced both hands on the side of the truck bed, and dropped her head between her arms.
The tank top rode up. There was a strip of skin above the waistband of her jeans, tan, flat, with the sharp cut of a hipbone, and I was looking at it — I was looking right at it, like an animal, in broad daylight, in front of a sign about nightcrawlers — when she lifted her head and looked straight across two pumps at me.
I looked at Dolores’s tire with enormous interest.
Do not, I told myself. Do not, Marnie. You have a dead car, a lie with sixty witnesses, and Tuesday. This is not the day you develop a type.
I peeked.
She was still looking. Not in a creepy way. In a considering way. Her gaze went from me, to Dolores with the hood still up like a gaping mouth, to the binder visible through the back window, and back to me. One corner of her mouth went up.
I became aware, all at once, of everything about myself. The claw clip holding half my hair to my skull at an angle that could only be described as structural. The sweat stain under my left boob from three hours in a car whose AC worked only when it felt seen. The sundress I’d put on that morning because it made my waist look good and my ass look great, and which now had a long smear of Dolores’s engine on the hip where I’d leaned in to look at the fuel pump like I’d know a fuel pump if it introduced itself.
My eyebrows, which have never once in my life been on my side, did something. I don’t know what. I felt them go up and then sort of crumple in the middle, broadcasting what I can only assume was I’m having the worst day of my life and also I noticed your hipbone.
The woman at Pump 4 raised one dark eyebrow back. Calm. Amused. Like she’d received the transmission in full.
Then she pushed off the truck and walked into the convenience store.
I let out a breath I hadn’t known I was holding and opened my notes app with shaking thumbs.
6. lake
7. do NOT
My phone rang at 4:52. It was Toni, which meant it was a phone call, which meant the texts hadn’t worked, which meant escalation.
I considered letting it go to voicemail. I have let my sister go to voicemail before. Once, in 2021, for an entire weekend. She drove to my apartment on Monday morning with a casserole and a locksmith.
“Hi,” I said. “Hi, Toni. Hello.”
“Oh, hello,” said my sister, in the bright, warm, totally lethal voice she uses on kindergarten teachers and phone companies. “Hello, Marnie, hello, how are you, I’m great, I’m thirty-four weeks pregnant in July and my ankles look like bread loaves. Where are you?”
“On the way.”
“On the way where? You were supposed to be at the lake by four. Nonna called the house phone at the lake to see if you got there and nobody answered and she called me and now she thinks you’re dead.”
“I’m not dead.”
“I told her that. I said, Nonna, she’s not dead, she’s just Marnie. She said how do you know, and honestly I didn’t have a good answer.” A pause. In the background I could hear Leo shrieking and Paulie saying, in his eternally patient Paulie way, Buddy, the dog is not a horse. “Where are you actually?”
I looked at Dolores. “Car trouble. Tiny. Little bit. I’m handling it.”
“Do you need Paulie to come get you?”
“No!” Too loud. Earl, inside the garage, looked up. I lowered my voice. “No. I’m fine. Everything’s fine. I’ll be there soon.”
“Good. Okay. Good.” I heard her take a breath, and I knew, with the instinct of a younger sibling, that she’d been building to this. “So. Listen. Not to be a pain.”
“You’ve never once in your life been a pain.”
“Thank you. Aunt Carm needs the name.”
I closed my eyes.
“For the place card,” Toni went on. “She’s doing them all by hand, Marn, in cross-stitch, with little lemons on them, it’s insane, she’s been on the porch for three days, she did Father Pete’s already, she did the dog’s — and she’s got yours done, Marnie, with a lemon, beautiful, and then there’s just an empty card next to it. Blank. She keeps holding it up to the light like it’s going to tell her something. She asked me if your girlfriend has a short name or a long name because she has to buy more thread.”
“It’s—” I said.
“And Nonna wants to know if she eats veal, because she’s doing the vitello tonnato Saturday, and if she doesn’t eat veal Nonna wants to know why, because she might be able to fix it.”
“Toni—”
“And Aunt Dee is very nervous that she’s going to be tall because she bought her a sweatshirt in a medium. Don’t ask me why she bought her a sweatshirt. It says CASTELLANO LAKE HOUSE EST. 1962 on it. She got everyone sweatshirts. Even Paulie’s mother. You know how Dee is.”
“I do know how Dee is.”
“And Chrissy has a theory.”
My eyes opened. Across the lot, the convenience store door swung open with a jingle, and the woman from Pump 4 walked out holding something in each hand. I didn’t look. I didn’t look.
“Chrissy,” I said carefully, “has a lot of theories.”
“She thinks you made her up.”
There is a particular kind of cold that starts at the base of your skull and runs all the way down to your heels. I stood in it, in ninety-degree heat, beside a sign advertising worms.
“That’s crazy,” I said. “That’s — Chrissy listens to too many podcasts. That’s insane.”
“That’s what I said! I said, Chrissy, why would anybody make up a girlfriend? That’s the saddest thing I ever heard.” Toni laughed. It was a fond laugh. It was the laugh of a woman who has never once in her life needed to lie about being loved. “But you know how she is. She said, quote, ‘In seven months Marnie has not posted one photo, used one pronoun, or mentioned one restaurant. That’s not private, Toni. That’s a witness protection program.’ End quote.”
“That’s —” I said, and my voice came out very high and very formal, which is what happens when I’m cornered, like I’m about to be presented at court. “That’s absolutely fine. Everything’s fine. Chrissy’s very funny.”
“So you’ll bring her,” Toni said, and her voice changed — went softer, the way it used to when we were kids and I’d had a nightmare and climbed into her bed. “Right, Marn? You’re bringing her. Because Nonna — I’m not trying to make it a whole thing. But Nonna’s eighty. And she really wants this. She talks about it every Sunday. She asked Father Pete to bless her. Your girlfriend. She asked a priest to bless a person she’s never met. She’s so happy, Marnie. You have no idea how happy you made her.”
I did have an idea. I’d had an idea every Sunday for seven months.
Across the lot, the woman from Pump 4 had stopped by the picnic table. She was looking at me. She was looking right at me, and I was looking back, and I could not have told you, then or later, what my face was doing.
“You are bringing her,” Toni said. “Right?”
I opened my mouth. I thought about option one. I really did. I thought about it the way you think about jumping into a lake in April — the cold, the shock, how clean you’d feel after.
My throat closed like a fist.
“Yes, Toni,” I said. “I’m on my way. And yes — I’m bringing her.”
“Yes!” A shriek, a crash, Paulie in the background going What? What happened? “Okay. Okay! I’m telling Nonna. I’m telling Carm. What’s her name? Marnie, what’s her—”
I hung up on my sister.
I stood very still. The lake glittered. A pickup with a canoe strapped to the top went by on Route 14 and honked at nobody. Inside the garage, Earl’s radio was playing a Bills preseason call-in show, a man named Gary explaining to the host why this, finally, was the year.
I’d done it. Again. Seven months of interest, and I’d just taken out a second mortgage.
I opened my notes app. I looked at the list. I put my thumb on 3. Produce a human and held it there, like I could press it hard enough to make it real.
And behind me, close, a voice said, “Hey.”
I turned around.
She was standing about three feet away. Up close she was even taller — I was eye level with her collarbone, which was a very good collarbone, sharp under tan skin, with a thin gold chain lying in the hollow of her throat. She smelled like sawdust and sun and a little bit of gasoline. She was holding two slushies, one in each big, square hand: one bright, unnatural cherry-red, the other a blue raspberry so blue it looked radioactive.
She held out the red one. When she smiled, I saw that her front tooth was chipped — a little corner missing, like somebody had taken a careful bite of her.
“You looked like you needed sugar,” she said. Her voice was low and dry and very calm, like she was talking a cat down out of a tree. “Machine only does two flavors. I figured you for cherry.”
I took the slushie. My hand was not steady. It was very cold.
“Thank you,” I said. “That’s — thank you. That’s so kind. I’m fine. I’m totally fine. I’m just having a—”
“Yeah, I heard,” she said.
She tipped her head toward Dolores, then toward my phone, still glowing in my other hand with the list on it. Then those dark eyes came back to mine, steady and amused, with something underneath the amusement that I didn’t have a name for yet.
She took a long, slow pull of the blue slushie, considered me over the straw, and asked, very reasonably, “Her who?”
Want to keep reading? The full novel is available now at all major retailers and direct from our store.
🔥 Want an EXCLUSIVE Bonus Chapter?
The Honeymoon Package — A scene TOO HOT for the bookstore
A year after the calibration kiss, the newlyweds check back into the Wren House on Keuka. Same suite. Same door. Same rose-petal heart, spelled right this time. And Jess finally finishes what she stopped.
More from Riley Kendra
Browse all Riley Kendra books.

Fake Girlfriend, Real Orgasms
She hired a stranger to be her girlfriend for four days. The walls were thinner than the lie.

Seven Nights With My Ex
Separate cabins. Seven rules. Sixty-one steps between her door and mine.

Eight Nights Next Door
Two rooms. One balcony. A wall of rosemary nobody crosses without asking.

The Final Date Is Off Camera
Twelve nights. Cameras in every room. Except one.

The Divorce Trip Committee
Six nights. One villa. Two lists. Zero chill.

The Best Woman
Two best women. One Lake Como wedding. A door that only opens from both sides.
Never Miss a Release
Get new release alerts, exclusive bonus content, and reader-only giveaways.
