House Rules — The Anniversary
An exclusive Practice Makes Poly bonus chapter
by Isla Wilde
One year after the verdict. One cabin. One unfinished constitution. Contains spoilers for Practice Makes Poly — read the book first!
Harper
The cabin was Eli’s idea, which means it has a fireplace, a hot tub, no cell service, and a raccoon situation he has already described as “promising.”
The agenda was mine. Of course it was. One year to the day since the verdict — since I tore the exit clause out of a legal pad and three people threw it in the air like confetti — and in my bag, in a folder, rides the unfinished business of this family: the Part Two menu. It has hung on our fridge for a year holding exactly two rules in my handwriting. Total honesty. Attendance mandatory. Forever.
Well. The forever part isn’t written yet. That’s the agenda.
The drive up is three hours of winter highway and one sustained argument about the playlist, which Noah wins by producing a queue titled ANNIVERSARY — v4 FINAL (REAL) that turns out to be every song that has ever mattered to us in chronological order, starting with the one from the terrible rooftop party and ending with the kitchen song, and by the time we crunch up the snow-packed drive nobody is arguing about anything, and Eli’s hand is on my knee, and Noah keeps looking at us in the rearview like a man checking his cargo of something priceless.
The cabin is honest wood and old quilts and a stone fireplace tall enough to stand in. Eli walks the perimeter the way I once walked his apartment, touching things — the mantel, the ax by the door, the window with the whole frozen lake in it — and pronounces it “structurally sound, morally questionable,” which is the family’s highest rating.
“Weekend rules,” I announce, spreading the menu on the scarred oak table while Noah stacks firewood with load-path commentary and Eli unpacks enough garlic knots to survive a siege. “We finish the constitution. One rule per session. Nobody drafts sober rules for this family — we earn them.”
Eli looks up, slow, the grin arriving like weather. “Define session.“
“You know exactly what I mean.”
“I want it in the minutes anyway.”
“Motion carries,” Noah says, from the fireplace, without turning around, and the weekend convenes itself.
Friday night doesn’t count toward the agenda, and we all know it going in. Friday night is arrival energy — wine by the fire, the hot tub steaming against a sky with more stars than Eli’s preserve, the three of us shoulder to shoulder in the water while the cold bites our faces and the heat holds everything else. Nobody starts anything. That’s what makes it unbearable, deliciously: three people who know exactly where the weekend is going, letting it idle. Eli’s foot finds mine under the water. Noah’s arm lies along the tub’s edge behind us both, fingertips tracing lazy nothings on my shoulder, on Eli’s neck, absent and possessive at once, and we stay in until we’re drunk on heat and starlight, and then we towel off shivering and pile into a bed that — Eli checks, first thing, the man has priorities — comfortably fits three.
“Big day tomorrow,” I say primly, to the dark, from the middle.
“She’s scheduling us,” Eli stage-whispers across me. “A year in and she’s still scheduling us.”
“The whiteboard walked so this weekend could run,” Noah says, and gets a pillow in the face, and we fall asleep laughing in a heap like the whole last year practiced us for exactly this.
Saturday morning belongs to Eli and me, because Noah declares — transparently, adorably — that the firewood “needs restacking” and takes his coffee to the porch with the smug expression of a man gifting his partners a session and planning to enjoy every muffled minute of it through the wall.
Eli starts slow on purpose, because a year ago slow was the thing he had to learn and now it’s the thing he weaponizes. He makes coffee first. He makes coffee elaborately, the good stuff he’s been saving for an occasion again, and hands me the chipped mug and watches me drink it standing at the frost-laced window in nothing but his flannel, and does not touch me, and narrates precisely what he’s not doing yet in that low bartender register until my hands aren’t steady on the mug.
“You,” I manage, “are running a filibuster.”
“I’m establishing the record.” He crosses the room at last, takes the mug out of my hands, sets it on the sill — click, like a starting gun, his oldest trick, it works every single time — and backs me into the sun-warmed wall. “One year, Quinn. I get to take my time with the anniversary testimony.”
And he does. He lays me out across a bed that smells like cedar while frost melts off the windows, and he goes through the whole archive item by item, mouth and hands and that ruinous voice, entering each exhibit into the record against my skin: the truth-or-drink night. The knock instead of the key. The stars I thought he’d forgotten — he traces the constellations he studied off a video, one by one, down the length of me, and I come apart the first time before he’s anywhere near done, with his name and a laugh tangled in the same breath. He works me back up again slow and merciless, all patience and filthy tenderness, until the second one rolls through me like weather and I have to press my face into his shoulder to keep the porch from getting the full transcript — a courtesy, it turns out, I fail to extend, because from outside comes Noah’s voice, warm and dry and shameless:
“The firewood and I heard that.“
“GOOD,” Eli calls back, not stopping, and finishes his testimony thorough and unhurried while I laugh and gasp and swear at both of them, and afterward he props himself over me, catastrophic hair backlit by winter sun, wrecked and certain, and says, hoarse: “Got my rule.”
We add it to the menu at the kitchen table, his seismograph scrawl under my two neat lines, while Noah comes in stamping snow off his boots and pretending he wasn’t listening at the wall like a Victorian. Rule 3: Nobody gets memorized for leaving. Only for keeping.
“Strong opening,” Noah says, reading it over our shoulders, one hand settling warm on the back of Eli’s neck. “The firewood and I are very moved.”
Saturday afternoon is theirs, and I take the porch shift with a quilt and the good thermos, because fair is fair, and because a year in, watching my men disappear into a cabin together still lights me up like the first movie night.
It starts, because they are who they are, as a fight about the fire. I can hear it through the window — Noah explaining airflow with diagrams implied in his voice, Eli dismantling the argument out of pure recreational spite, the two of them shoulder to shoulder at the hearth in the oldest choreography they own — and I could call the ending from the porch with my eyes closed: the bicker compressing, the pauses arriving, the specific silence that has always, since a dorm room in 2016, meant one beat away. Then the beat. Then no more airflow discourse of any kind.
I don’t watch this one. I listen — the fire cracking, the low rumble of two voices going quiet, then quieter, then not quiet at all. Noah’s laugh cracking into something else entirely. Eli’s voice dropping into the register that started a whole year of this, rough and reverent by turns, and then wordless where it counts, the way it’s always been between them — except for the one word, the paid-for word, which surfaces over and over through the wall like a coin dropped in a jar they’re still filling: boyfriend, boyfriend, boyfriend. There’s a stretch in the middle where the whole cabin goes so still I can hear the lake ice settle, and I know exactly what that stillness is — I’ve governed it from an armchair — the eye-contact stretch, the vow-speed stretch — and I sit in the cold gold light with my coffee, sovereign and patient and outrageously fond, while somewhere behind me the boy who once couldn’t say a word to his own mother spends a whole hour saying nothing but.
They emerge an hour and change later, flushed and ruined and unbearably pleased with themselves, wearing each other’s shirts — not by accident, nothing they do is by accident anymore — and Noah writes his rule with the pen held in both hands like a ceremony. Rule 4: Say it where it costs. Then say it where it doesn’t, constantly, for free.
“Boyfriend,” Eli adds, to no one, to the cabin, just because he can.
“Boyfriend,” Noah agrees, mild as arithmetic, and kisses him in front of the whole frozen lake.
Saturday night is all of us, and it is the whole year distilled.
It starts in the kitchen, because every cornerstone we own is load-tested in one: Eli cooking, whiteboard-lawful even on vacation, the kitchen song coming up on ANNIVERSARY — v4 FINAL (REAL) exactly when Noah engineered it to, and the three of us stop, and grin, and dance. Badly. In wool socks, on old pine boards, Noah spun into the refrigerator on schedule, me handed between them like the answer to an old argument — and this time when Eli catches my hand mid-spin he doesn’t stop, he reels me all the way in, and Noah closes in behind me, and the dancing stops being dancing standing up.
Dinner is late. Dinner is very late. Nobody files a complaint.
Afterward we build the fire up to a roar and drag every blanket and quilt the cabin owns onto the floor in front of it, and the three of us come together in the firelight the way only a year of practice makes possible — no choreography needed and none surviving, slow and greedy and lavish by turns, the middle of the bed reconvened on a floor in the woods. Noah directs, sleeves shoved up, voice low and precise and completely gone at the edges. Eli narrates until he can’t, until the patter burns off and there’s nothing under it but the true things, our names said like facts. I govern, sovereign in the middle of my country, taking the anniversary tribute from both borders at once — two mouths, two sets of hands, one year of fluency — and giving it back with interest, until the fire is embers and we’ve burned through every version of thank you for staying the three of us can invent, one after another after another, and collapsed into the quilt wreckage in a heap of slowing heartbeats and firelight.
“Minutes,” I murmur, eventually, from the middle, boneless.
“Attendance,” Noah manages, wrecked, into my hair, “was—”
“Don’t you dare,” Eli says. “Not yet. Save it. I’ve got a feeling about that one.”
And in the shipwrecked after, tangled in firelight with a heartbeat under each ear, I reach for the folder without getting up — long practice — and put the menu on Noah’s chest and the pen in Eli’s hand.
“Last one,” I say. “Together. That’s the rule about the rule.”
So we write it in three hands, passing the pen around the pile — Noah’s tidy print, my slanted case-file letters, Eli’s beautiful disaster — and when it’s done we hold the menu up to the firelight and read our constitution complete:
Rule 5: Attendance. Was. Excellent.
“That’s not a rule,” Noah objects, already laughing.
“It’s a founding fact,” Eli says. “Look it up.”
“It’s a forever,” I say, and neither of them argues, because it is — because that was always the last rule, hiding in the first joke, the way everything true about this family started as a bit and stayed as a vow.
Sunday morning, I wake in the middle of the quilt pile to winter light and the smell of pancakes.
Eli is at the stove with measuring cups — he travels with them now; we don’t discuss it — and Noah is at the table with the completed menu flattened in front of him, photographing it for Rosa’s thread, and there’s a mug of the good coffee waiting at my place, the chipped one, which apparently also travels. I stand in the doorway in somebody’s flannel — provenance disputed, all shirts are commons now — and look at the whole scene for a long minute: the fire down to warm ash, the lake blazing white through the window, my two ceremonial idiots in their Sunday operations, the constitution finished on the table between the syrup and the pen.
Eli catches me looking. “She’s memorizing,” he tells Noah.
“Rule three permits it,” Noah says. “For keeping only.”
For keeping. That’s the whole constitution, if you’re taking minutes: three keys on three matching rings, one mug on the second shelf, one middle of one bed, five rules on a takeout menu that goes home taped to a fridge in a palace with our names on the lease —
— and forever, ratified by unanimous vote, in front of a fire, out loud.
Motion carries.
Loved Harper, Noah & Eli?
If you enjoyed Practice Makes Poly, a review on Amazon means the world to indie authors — even one sentence helps other readers find the triad.
Never Miss a Release
Get new release alerts, exclusive bonus content, and reader-only giveaways.