If You Liked Heated Rivalry or The Deal, Read These Next: The Ultimate Hockey Romance Guide
Finding your next 5-star hockey romance can feel like a full-time job. You’ve devoured Rachel Reid’s Game Changers and memorized every line of Elle Kennedy’s Off-Campus series. You’re chasing that specific high: the locker room tension, the forced proximity, and the grumpy players who are soft for exactly one person.
Whether you’re looking for MM enemies-to-lovers that rivals Ilya and Shane, or MF fake dating that gives you major Garrett Graham vibes, we have the perfect indie recommendations to cure your book hangover.
Here are the best read-alikes for the most popular hockey romance tropes.
1. If you loved Heated Rivalry by Rachel Reid…
Read: Puck Tease by Chase Power
The Vibe: Grumpy Captain vs. Sunshine Rookie | Forced Proximity
Fans of Rachel Reid know that the magic lies in the tension between two players who shouldn’t want each other but can’t stay away.
Why it works: Like the legendary Ilya Rozanov, Silas Kincaid in Puck Tease is a veteran captain with walls of steel. He is serious, broody, and absolutely done with everyone’s nonsense. Enter Nico, a rookie who is basically human glitter.
The Hook: Just like in Heated Rivalry, the chemistry here is built on the ice and solidified in secret. When Nico’s apartment floods and he has to move in with Silas (hello, forced proximity), the “stay out of my way” energy quickly turns into “come here and make me.”
Keywords: MM Sports Romance, Grumpy Sunshine, Age Gap, Enemies to Lovers.
2. If you loved The Deal by Elle Kennedy…
Read: The Blurred Playbook by Rowan Black
The Vibe: Fake Dating | Tutor x Jock | Competence Kink
Elle Kennedy set the gold standard for college hockey romance with the “tutor meets jock” trope. If you miss the banter between Garrett and Hannah, The Blurred Playbook is your next obsession.
Why it works: Jax Donovan is hockey royalty tanking his classes; Sadie Sinclair is the brilliant student manager who agrees to help him. They strike a fake dating deal to save his reputation, but the lines blur fast.
The Hook: It flips the script on the “dumb jock” stereotype. Jax has undiagnosed dyslexia, and Sadie is the only one who takes the time to understand how his brain works. It’s spicy, emotional, and features a hero who is utterly devoted to the woman who helps him succeed.
Keywords: MF Hockey Romance, Fake Dating, Academic Rivals, Coach’s Niece.
3. If you loved The Wall of Winnipeg and Me by Mariana Zapata…
Read: Roughing the Reporter by Rowan Black
The Vibe: Massive Grump vs. Tiny Sunshine | Workplace Romance | Slow Burn Payoff
Nobody does the “Grumpy Giant” better than Mariana Zapata, but Rowan Black is giving her a run for her money with Elias “The Anvil” Thorne.
Why it works: Elias is the team’s terrifying enforcer who literally scares people for a living. Sloan is the tiny, chaotic social media manager who has to wrangle him for TikToks.
The Hook: The secret sauce here? Elias secretly reads the spicy romance blog Sloan writes anonymously. He knows he’s the inspiration for her fantasies before she even admits she likes him. The size difference and the “who did this to you” protectiveness are top-tier.
Keywords: Enforcer Romance, Workplace Trope, Secret Identity, Size Difference.
4. If you loved Him by Sarina Bowen & Elle Kennedy…
Read: The Enforcer’s Luck by Jax Wilder
The Vibe: Friends to Lovers | Bi-Awakening | Hurt/Comfort
Sarina Bowen and Elle Kennedy are masters of the “friends to lovers” dynamic where one realization changes everything.
Why it works: Ford is an aging enforcer terrified his career is ending; Luca is the star player who becomes his anchor. What starts as a superstitious “good luck” ritual in the showers evolves into a soul-deep connection.
The Hook: The bi-awakening is handled with such care and heat. Ford has spent his life thinking he’s just a brute, but Luca shows him he’s worthy of a soft, domestic love. It’s angsty, sweaty, and incredibly sweet.
Keywords: MM Hockey, Bi-Awakening, Teammates to Lovers, Hurt/Comfort.
5. If you loved Role Model by Rachel Reid…
Read: The King’s Submission by Jax Wilder
The Vibe: The Hated Villain | Redemption Arc | Soft Boy x Grump
Everyone loves a redemption story. If you lived for Troy “The Ogre” Barrett finding love, you need to meet Damon “The King” Kingsley.
Why it works: Damon is the league’s villain—hated, suspended, and isolated. Emmett is the quiet equipment manager who treats him like a human being.
The Hook: This is for readers who love the “Us Against the World” trope. The locker room hates Damon, but in the sanctuary of the equipment room, he melts for Emmett. It proves that even the “bad guys” of hockey deserve a happily ever after.
Keywords: Redemption Romance, Player x Staff, Power Dynamics, Grumpy Softie.
Ready to Find Your Next Hockey Romance Obsession?
Browse all our sports romance books or explore our MM romance collection.
