
Don’t Call Him a Phase
An MM Best Friends to Lovers Romance
by Jace Wilder

Free with Kindle Unlimited
Pairing: MM
Heat: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Inferno
Tropes: Best Friends to Lovers, Age Gap, Bisexual Awakening, Coming Out, First Time MM, Sex Lessons, Practice Turns Real, Written Rules, Secret Relationship, Mutual Pining, Lake Cabin Weekend, Praise Kink, Dirty Talk, Love Letter, Real Grovel, Found Family, Hurt/Comfort, No Cheating, HEA
Six years of best friends. One index card of rules. One word he swore he’d never be again.
Theo Bennett is twenty-eight and about to open the first thing that has ever been his: Groundwork, a strength gym in an old mill on the Calder Point waterfront. He has also just figured out something he probably should have figured out years ago. He’s bi. He’s sure. He has just never been with a man, and he’d rather not learn on a stranger.
So he asks the person he trusts most. Adrian Cole: thirty-five, graphic designer, heron tattoo along his ribs, a Rotring pen in his shirt pocket. Six years of friendship, four years of Wednesday coffee at the same café table. His best friend.
Adrian says yes. On terms. Three of them, in block capitals on a three-by-five card:
1. NO SLEEPOVERS.
2. NOBODY KNOWS.
3. IT ENDS WHEN YOU’VE FIGURED IT OUT.
Theo takes the pen and adds one of his own, bigger than the rest:
4. YOU DON’T GET TO TELL ME WHAT I FEEL.
Theo is a fast learner and a terrible rule-follower. The more he learns, the clearer it gets that what he’s figuring out isn’t men in general. It’s Adrian.
Adrian already knows how this ends. Eight years ago another man called him an experimental phase in front of a room full of people, and Adrian has been quietly writing his own ending ever since. Theo will figure it out. Theo will move on. Adrian will be the friend who helped.
So when the lessons start to feel real, Adrian does the one thing Theo asked him never to do. He stands on a rooftop full of people and decides out loud what Theo feels.
Now Adrian has to learn the hardest lesson of all, and no rule card is going to save him.
Don’t Call Him a Phase is a high-heat MM age-gap romance with best friends to lovers, a bisexual awakening, sex lessons with written rules, a secret relationship, first-time MM, praise and dirty talk, a lake-cabin weekend, a love letter, a real grovel with real accountability, found family, a lot of on-page spice, no cheating, and a guaranteed HEA. Dual POV. Complete standalone romance.
You’ll love this book if you enjoy:
✅ Index-card rules written in a Rotring pen, and the fourth rule that was always the only one that mattered
✅ A best friend who teaches him everything, then forgets he was never supposed to fall
✅ “First time with a man” written like it actually matters
✅ A gym owner who coaches the way he loves: patient, loud, and all the way
✅ Praise that undoes a careful, composed designer one “look at you” at a time
✅ A lake-cabin weekend and the night they break Rule 1
✅ A grovel with real accountability: therapy, apologies made in person, and a letter that does the work
✅ A boardwalk, a new card, and a proposal on a crooked dock with two herons watching
✅ Age gap, bisexual awakening, no cheating, 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ heat, HEA guaranteed
⚠️ Content Warning: This novel contains explicit sexual content (graphic MM scenes, including first-time sex between men, oral and anal sex, praise, and dirty talk; all on-page sex is consensual), a character coming out as bisexual, biphobic remarks and a character being publicly described as a “phase,” anxiety, fear of abandonment and self-sabotage, a painful breakup and its emotional fallout, therapy, alcohol, and strong language. No cheating, no sexual violence, no dub-con. Intended for readers 18+.
📖 Read Chapter One Free
Not sure yet? Read all of Chapter One right here.
Chapter One: Theo
The squat rack instructions are in four languages, and they’re wrong in all of them.
Step nine says insert bolt C through upright B. There is no bolt C. There are eleven bolt Ds, a bag of washers that look like they came from a different rack entirely, and a hex key so small it was clearly designed by a man with delicate wrists and no intention of ever lifting anything.
It’s 6:04 a.m. Sun’s coming in sideways through the mill windows, long gold bars across the rubber floor, and I’ve been here since five because I couldn’t sleep and this is cheaper than therapy.
I lean my weight into the upright, line up the holes, and drive the bolt home with the heel of my hand. The hex key slips. My knuckle hits steel.
“Fuck. Okay. Cool.”
Blood. Not much. I suck it off and look around at what I’ve got so far.
Groundwork. Four thousand square feet on the second floor of the old Hargrove Mill. Exposed brick, beams the size of my body, windows that open if you’re mean to them. Half the floor is laid. One rig is up. The other’s in pieces at my feet. There’s a pallet of bumper plates shrink-wrapped by the door and a chalk bucket I bought before I bought a desk, because priorities. In seven weeks, if the lender doesn’t change its mind and the electrician shows up when he says, people are going to walk in here and pay me money to make them strong.
Seven years coaching other people’s clients at a gym with a smoothie bar and mirrored walls and a sales quota, and this is the first thing that’s mine. Every dollar in it is mine or the bank’s. Mostly the bank’s. The spreadsheet Lena built me has a cell that turns red when I’m within two thousand dollars of zero, and it’s been red since April.
I’m not thinking about the spreadsheet.
I’m thinking about what I’m going to say to Adrian at nine thirty.
I’ve said it in the shower. I’ve said it on the drive over. I said it out loud to the bumper plates twenty minutes ago and they took it fine, but they’re bumper plates.
Here’s the short version, the one I’ve been carrying since spring like a stone in my pocket.
Hannah and I ended in September. Two years, good ones mostly, and we ended because she wanted Denver and I wanted this, and nobody was lying. After, there was a lot of quiet, and in the quiet I started noticing things I’d been stepping around for years. The way I watched certain guys at work and called it professional interest. The way I’d tell myself I was admiring a man’s build the same way I’d admire a well-made truck. One performer I kept going back to, three, four, nine times, and not for the woman in the scene. I filed all of it under nothing.
Then March. The climbing gym on Dock Street, a Thursday, Adrian coming off the overhang with his shirt soaked dark down the spine, chalk on his jaw, laughing at something I’d said. Just laughing. Head back, mouth open. That mouth. I drove home and jerked off against my kitchen counter thinking about it, and when I was done I stood there with my forehead on the cabinet and thought: Oh. Okay. So that’s what that is.
Not just him. I want to be clear about that, even to myself. It’s men and it’s women and it’s been both the whole time. I told my sister in April over terrible Thai food, and Maya put down her fork and said, “Huh. Yeah, I can see that,” and then, “Is it Adrian?” and I threw a spring roll at her.
Bisexual. I’ve said the word out loud maybe twenty times. It fits. It fits like the navy jacket Adrian made me buy, the one I complained about for an hour in the store and then wore four days in a row.
It’s not a question. It’s an answer I took too long to find.
The question is the other thing.
I finish the bolt, wrap my knuckle in athletic tape, and check the time. 6:40. Three hours to stop being a coward.
Hollis Café smells like burnt sugar and wet dogs, because the owner lets everybody bring their dogs, and it’s been our place every Wednesday for four years. Adrian is already at the window table when I get there, which is a crime against nature, because Adrian is never early for anything except this.
He’s ordered for me. Large drip, black, everything bagel with enough cream cheese to grout a bathroom. His own cortado sits in front of him, half gone. He’s in a white linen shirt with the sleeves turned back twice, precisely, the way he does everything, and his hair is doing the thing where it falls in his eyes and he lets it, because he knows.
He doesn’t know. That’s the thing about Adrian. He thinks he’s hiding in plain sight, and he’s just in plain sight.
“You’re bleeding,” he says, without looking up from his phone.
“I’m taped.”
“You’re bleeding through the tape.” He looks up. Gray-green eyes, a little bloodshot. He was up late too. “Who’d you fight?”
“A squat rack.”
“Did you win?”
“It’s standing. I’m standing. Call it a draw.” I sit. The chair creaks under me the way every chair in this place creaks under me. “Thanks for the bagel.”
“You’d have ordered the muffin and regretted it.” He turns his phone around and slides it across the table. “Before anything. I need you to see this. I need a witness.”
It’s a photo of a billboard off Route 31. A chiropractor, grinning, thumbs up, and in letters three feet tall: BACK PAIN? WE’VE GOT YOUR BACK. AND YOUR FRONT. ASK ABOUT COUPLES ADJUSTMENTS.
I laugh so hard a woman two tables over looks at me.
“Couples adjustments,” Adrian says, deadly serious. “What is he adjusting. Where are his hands.”
“That’s a lawsuit. That’s a billboard for a lawsuit.”
“Someone approved that. Someone sat in a meeting, and the kerning—look at the kerning, Theo, the kerning is fine. Somebody cared about the kerning and nobody cared about the sentence.”
“That’s your trauma talking.”
“My trauma has an excellent eye.” He takes the phone back. “Your turn.”
I pull up mine. A food truck at the Saturday market, hand-painted: TACOS SO GOOD YOU’LL SLAP YOUR ABUELA. Below it, smaller, in a different color: (PLEASE DO NOT SLAP YOUR ABUELA).
Adrian puts a hand over his eyes. His shoulders shake. When he drops the hand he’s flushed down to the open collar of the shirt, and I watch the color go and do not think about where it ends.
I absolutely think about where it ends.
This is the easy part. Six years of this. Him, me, a table, a bad sign, the way he laughs with his whole face when he forgets to be composed.
I met him on the worst day of my twenties. I was twenty-two and showing off on the bouldering wall at the climbing co-op, and I peeled off a crimp and caught my face on a hold on the way down. Blood everywhere. A stranger with a first-aid kit and a voice like a library said, “Sit. Don’t touch it. You’re going to have a very attractive scar and you’re going to tell everyone you got it rescuing a child.” He taped me up. He drove me to urgent care in a Honda that smelled like spray fixative. I never paid him back for the co-pay.
He was twenty-nine, and I thought he was the most adult person I’d ever met. Now I know better. Now I know he alphabetizes his spices and cries at news footage of bridge collapses and cannot parallel park to save his life.
I still have the scar. Left eyebrow, a pale line straight through it. Sometimes he looks at it like he’s checking his work.
“So,” he says. “Rack’s standing. Lender?”
“Lender’s being a lender. I’ll know Friday.”
“Electrician?”
“Says Tuesday.”
“Which Tuesday.”
“He didn’t specify.” I tear the bagel in half. I’m not hungry. I eat it anyway, because my hands need a job. “It’s fine. It’s seven weeks.”
“Company or solutions?”
It’s our thing. It’s been our thing since the year he lost a huge client and I showed up with a twelve-pack and a whole plan for diversifying his revenue, and he looked at me like I’d shot his dog. Ask first, he said. Do you want me to fix it, or do you want me to sit here? We’ve asked each other ever since.
“Company,” I say. “Today it’s just company.”
“Okay.” He settles back. Waits. Adrian’s good at waiting. It’s one of the things that drives me up the wall about him, and one of the things I’d pay good money to have pointed at me in a dark room.
I put the bagel down.
“I want to tell you something,” I say. “And I need you to let me get all the way through it.”
His eyebrows go up. He sets down the cortado. “That’s ominous. Are you dying? Are you moving to Denver?”
“Nobody’s moving to Denver.”
“Hannah moved to Denver.”
“Adrian.”
“Sorry. Go.” He folds his hands on the table. “All the way through. I’m a vault.”
I’ve rehearsed it fourteen ways. None of them survive contact with his face.
“I’m bisexual,” I say.
It comes out clean. That surprises me. No crack, no stall. Just the word, sitting on the table between the bagel and his phone like it’s always been part of the order.
Adrian goes still. Not frozen. Still the way a person goes when they’re listening with their whole body.
Then his face does something I’ve never seen it do. It softens all at once, every line letting go. “Theo.”
“I’ve known for a while. Couple months for sure. Longer if I’m honest, I just didn’t have a word for the drawer I was putting it in.” I shrug. My shoulders feel huge and stupid. “Maya knows. You’re the second person.”
“I’m—” He presses his lips together. He looks like he might actually tear up, which is extremely on brand. “Thank you. For telling me. I’m really glad you did. Are you okay? Of course you’re okay, you look okay, you look—” He stops, starts again. “This is good. This is a good thing. I’m proud of you.”
“Thanks.”
“Seriously. That’s not nothing. Coming out at twenty-eight, after—” He catches himself. “Not that there’s a right age. There’s no right age. I came out at nineteen in a Wendy’s parking lot and threw up on my own shoes, so you’re already doing better than me.”
I grin. “You’ve told me.”
“It bears repeating.” And then I watch it happen. I watch Adrian Cole switch on. The designer, the fixer, the man who has a plan for every client who walks through his door. He leans in, eyes bright. “Okay. So. Have you thought about how you want to—I mean, do you want to meet people? Because you can let it just be a fact about yourself for a while, that’s allowed, but if you want to actually—” He waves a hand. “Apps are a nightmare, but they’re a necessary nightmare. Don’t use the one with the yellow logo, it’s all married men in Batavia. The other one’s better. Put up a photo where you’re actually smiling, not the gym one, everybody does the gym one. And Rochester has a couple of decent bars. There’s one on Alexander Street that’s low-key, nobody’s going to swarm you. Well. They’ll swarm you a little. Look at you. But respectfully.”
I don’t say anything. I let him run.
“And if you don’t want strangers, I know people. Not a lot of people. Some people. Marcus—you met Marcus at Farah’s thing, he does pottery, he’s very kind, he’d be patient with you. Or Ellis, though Ellis is a lot. Actually, no. Not Ellis. Ellis is a chapter you read when you’re older.” He laughs a little, at himself. “God, listen to me. I’m a matchmaker. I’m a Jane Austen aunt. You should tell me to shut up.”
He’s been going a full minute. I counted.
“You done?” I ask.
“I could make a spreadsheet.”
“Adrian.”
“Mostly done.”
“I’m not asking you for apps.” I lean forward, forearms on the table, and the table wobbles. I hold it steady with one hand. “I’m not asking for bars in Rochester. I’m not asking you to set me up with a potter.”
“He’s very good. He has a kiln.”
“I’m not asking whether men might want me.” I keep my voice level. I keep my eyes on his. “I’m asking whether you do.”
Silence.
Somebody’s French bulldog sneezes. The espresso machine screams. Adrian looks at me, and for one second something crosses his face, fast and naked and terrible, like a curtain blown back by wind.
Then he laughs.
“Okay,” he says. “Very good. You got me.”
“I’m not—”
“No, that was excellent, I walked right into it. You set it up and everything. ‘Let me get all the way through.’ Honestly, Theo, the commitment—” He reaches for his cortado. His hand isn’t steady. He sees me see it and sets the cup back down. “You’re joking.”
“I’m not joking.”
“You’re—”
“I have never been less funny in my life.” I hold his eyes. “I’m asking you out. I mean a date.”
He stares at me.
Then, slowly, he adjusts his left cuff. The one already folded perfectly. He turns it once more, flattens it with his thumb. He does it when a client asks him what something costs. He did it at his dad’s funeral, standing at the front, over and over, until Simon reached over and held his wrist.
He’s buying time.
“Theo,” he says, very gently, which is how I know it’s bad.
“You can just answer the question.”
“I’m trying to answer it well.”
“Answer it badly. I’m not grading.”
His jaw works. He looks out the window, at the lake lying flat and silver past the rooftops, at a guy walking three greyhounds. When he looks back, he’s lost a little of the polish, the way the edge of a page goes soft when it’s been handled too much.
“Obviously,” he says. Low. “Have you seen you?”
Heat climbs the back of my neck.
“Have you met yourself?” he goes on, and it’s like he can’t stop now that the lid’s off. “You walk into a room and every person in it reorganizes. You have forearms like a felony. You laughed at a billboard just now and that woman over there forgot what she was saying. Yes. Obviously. Of course I’ve—” He stops. Swallows. “That’s not the question.”
“That’s exactly the question. That’s the only question I asked.”
“Theo.”
“Do you want me?”
“Yes.” Flat, raw, fast. Then, quieter, like it slipped out the back door while he was guarding the front: “Yes.”
Something in my chest unclenches so hard I feel it in my hands. I’m grinning. I can’t help it. I’ve had this stone in my pocket for three months and he just took it out and told me it was a diamond.
“Okay,” I say. “Then go out with me. Friday. Saturday. I’ll cook. I’ll take you somewhere with tablecloths. Whatever you want.”
And I watch him close.
It’s not dramatic. It’s a door easing shut in another room. He sits back. The softness leaves his mouth. He gets reasonable, and I know Adrian well enough to know that’s the worst thing he can get.
“No,” he says.
I don’t move.
“Not because I don’t—you know it’s not that. You heard what I just said.” He spreads his hands on the table like he’s laying out a proof. “You’ve known about this for a couple of months. You’ve never been with a man. You haven’t even been on a date with one.”
“I’m aware.”
“And your very first one should be with—” He gestures at himself, a little helpless. “Your best friend? Your thirty-five-year-old best friend? The guy who drove you to urgent care? That’s not a date, Theo, that’s a field trip with a chaperone. You don’t want your first anything with a man to be with your best friend.”
“I really do, actually.”
“You think you do. Trust me.”
There it is.
I go still. I feel myself do it, the way I always do when somebody pats me on the head. It runs in the family. My mother used to say Theo’s thinking when I got like this as a kid, like it was cute. It was never thinking. It was me deciding whether to say the thing.
“Say that again,” I say.
He hears it. He winces. “I didn’t mean—”
“No, say it again. ‘Trust me.’ Trust you about what?”
“About how this goes.” He keeps his voice gentle, and the gentleness is worse than anything. “I’ve been where you are. I’ve watched people be where you are. It’s huge and it’s new and everything feels enormous, and you grab the closest, safest thing—”
“I didn’t grab anything. I asked.”
“—and six months later you’ve figured yourself out, and the closest, safest thing is just your friend again, except now you can’t look him in the eye at Wednesday coffee. And I’d lose you. Do you understand? I’d lose this.” He taps the table. Taps it again. “I’m not doing that to either of us.”
I sit back. I look at him for a long time. He holds it, and it costs him. I can see exactly what it costs him.
“I didn’t ask you to trust you,” I say. “I asked you out.”
His mouth opens. Nothing comes.
“And for the record,” I add, “I’m not where you were. I’m where I am. You’ve never sat here. Nobody has. It’s my chair.”
“Theo—”
“I’ve got a call with the lender at eleven.” I stand. The chair scrapes, and half the café looks over, and I don’t care. I pick up the coffee he bought me, because I’m not an animal. “Thanks for the bagel.”
“Please don’t leave angry.”
“I’m not angry.” I’m a little angry. “I’m going to work. You’re going to sit here and fix your cuffs.”
His hand stops halfway to his wrist.
I shoulder the door open and the bell jangles above me, bright and stupid. I make it half a block before I let myself think the thing I couldn’t say at the table.
He said yes.
He said yes and then he said no, and the yes is the one he meant.
The lender calls at 11:15 and says Friday. The electrician texts at two and says Thursday, which is not Tuesday, and I don’t have the energy to ask which one. Lena comes by with her laptop and tells me the red cell is a deeper red, and I tell her the bumper plates got delivered so at least something in my life is heavy and reliable, and she looks at me over her glasses and says, “Did something happen at coffee?”
“No.”
“Your ears are red.”
“It’s hot in here.”
“It’s sixty-eight in here, Theo. I set the thermostat.” She closes the laptop. “You don’t have to tell me. I don’t want you to tell me. I just want you to stop dropping bolts.”
I’ve dropped four bolts.
She leaves at six. I stay. I finish the second rig alone, which is stupid and slow and exactly what I need, and at nine thirty I’m still there, sitting on a plyo box under the work lights, sweat drying on my back, chalk to the elbows.
I’m furious.
Not at him. That’s the problem. I’m furious around him, at the shape of the thing he did. At trust me. At the way he said obviously like it had been sitting in his mouth for years, and he finally let it out, and then shoved it right back in before it could breathe.
How long?
That’s the thought I can’t put down. Have you seen you. The cup shaking in his hand. The way he went red into his collar. That wasn’t the face of a man who just noticed his friend’s forearms. That was the face of a man who got caught.
And then I’m thinking about his collar. About where the flush went. About his throat moving when he swallowed, and his mouth—that mouth, the one I’ve thought about every night since March—saying yes like it hurt to let it go.
I’m hard. Sitting on a plyo box in an empty gym, chalky and pissed off and hard as the steel I’ve been bolting all day.
“Great,” I tell the rack. “Fantastic. Thank you.”
I think about the way he’d kiss. I’ve thought about it before. Not tentative. Adrian isn’t tentative about anything he actually wants, only about the things he’s decided he shouldn’t have. He’d kiss the way he talks when he’s lit up about kerning. Precise. Thorough. Too much. I think about getting a hand in that hair and finding out whether he’d let me pull. Whether he’d make a sound. I think about the two inches between five eleven and six one, and how I’d close them.
I think about his hands. He has beautiful hands. Long fingers, ink along the side of his thumb half the time, a little callus from his pen. I’ve watched those hands draw logos on napkins for six years.
I want to know what they’d do on me. I want to know what they’d do wrapped around my cock, whether he’d be slow about it, whether he’d talk.
I press the heel of my palm down hard against myself through my shorts, once, and groan out loud in the empty room, and let go. I’m not doing this here. Not on my floor. Not about a man who told me he wanted me and then told me I didn’t know what I wanted in the same breath.
I go into the half-finished locker room and stand under the one working showerhead until the water runs cold, and then I stand under it some more.
He’s wrong.
That’s the clearest thing in my head, clearer than the want. He’s wrong, and he’s scared, and he thinks those are the same as being careful. I’ve watched him do it with clients for years. Knock his price down before anyone asks for a discount. Apologize for a concept before anyone’s seen it. He gets out ahead of the no so nobody else gets to say it to him.
He just did it to me.
At 11:30 I’m home, on my back on top of the covers in the dark, phone on my chest. I’ve typed four texts and deleted four.
I meant it.
Delete.
You don’t get to decide that for me.
True. Delete.
How long?
Delete. Too much. Not yet.
Thanks for the bagel.
That one I almost send. As a joke. As a white flag. Then I picture him reading it and going soft with relief, thinking we’re back to normal, thinking he won, and I delete it so hard I nearly drop the phone on my face.
I set it face down. I stare at the ceiling. The hardware store downstairs has a sign that hums all night, a low electric whine I stopped hearing years ago. I’m hearing it now.
At 11:48, the phone buzzes against my sternum.
I don’t grab it. I count to three. I grab it.
Adrian.
Come over. I have terms.
Want to keep reading? The full novel is free with Kindle Unlimited.
🔥 Want an EXCLUSIVE Bonus Chapter?
Terms of Engagement — A scene TOO HOT for the bookstore
The night he says yes, Adrian clips one more card to his drafting lamp. Lights stay on. Everything out loud. You don’t stop until I say the word. Theo accepts the terms. Adrian doesn’t tell him what the word is.
More from Jace Wilder
Browse all Jace Wilder books.

One Time Only (He Lied)
He said it was one time. He lied.

Your Side of My Bed
Four weeks, in pen. One thin wall. Eleven years of pretending.

Sixty Days’ Notice
Four years. One wall. Zero idea.

Back of House
He bought my family's ovens and turned them off. Now he wants me.

Under New Management
The founder retired. The successor stopped waiting.

Room for the Best Man
Two best men. One bathroom. A couch night he swore he forgot.
Never Miss a Release
Get new release alerts, exclusive bonus content, and reader-only giveaways.
