Penalty Box Daddy: The Reward
Exclusive Bonus Chapter
by Chase Power
⚠️ This bonus chapter takes place after the events of Penalty Box Daddy. It contains major spoilers and is intended for readers who have finished the novel. Content is explicit and rated 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ — too hot for Amazon.
The Reward
The apartment smelled like champagne and sweat and the specific, electric aftermath of a team that had just won their first playoff series in three years.
Wes was still buzzing. Not drunk — he’d had two beers at the team celebration and stopped, because Nolan had given him The Look from across the locker room and The Look meant I have plans for you and I need you present for them.
He’d driven to the apartment — their apartment — with the windows down and the night air cool on his face and the phantom weight of Nolan’s gaze on his skin. Twenty minutes. He’d parked in his spot. Second row, third from the end. Taken the stairs two at a time because the elevator was slow and every second between here and Nolan was a second he didn’t want.
The door was unlocked. He turned the handle. Pushed it open.
Nolan was in the bedroom doorway. Leaning against the frame. Arms crossed. Still in his dress shirt from the postgame — white, fitted, sleeves rolled to the elbows, the top two buttons undone. His forearms were braced against his chest, the veins standing out, the scar on his knuckle vivid under the lamplight. The thin white line above his eye — the scar from the hit he’d taken for Wes, the one that had started everything — caught the light.
His reading glasses were pushed up into his hair. He’d been waiting. Preparing.
“You took twenty-three minutes,” Nolan said.
“I drove the speed limit.”
“You’ve never driven the speed limit in your life.”
“I was savoring the anticipation.”
Nolan’s eyes did the thing. The almost-smile. The warmth that lived behind the gray when his mouth refused to participate. Then the warmth shifted — focused, sharpened, became something with edges. The film-room look. The look that said I’ve studied the tape and I know exactly what I’m going to do to you.
Wes’s cock thickened in his jeans. Pavlovian. The conditioned response that Nolan had trained into him over months of structured praise and deliberate touch — the feedback loop that connected good hockey to very good things happening in this bedroom.
“Two goals tonight,” Nolan said. His voice dropped into the lower register — the underneath voice, the one that bypassed Wes’s skin and went directly into his bloodstream. “Two assists. Plus-three. Series-clinching performance.”
“I was motivated.”
“You were extraordinary.” The word landed like a hand on bare skin. Like the first touch of a night that was going to take him apart. “And extraordinary earns a reward.”
“What kind of reward?”
Nolan pushed off the doorframe. Crossed the living room. Stood in front of Wes — inside the radius, inside the space that had been theirs since the first film session. Close enough that Wes could feel the heat of him, smell the aftershave and the clean cotton of his shirt and the warm, specific scent underneath that was just Nolan.
“The kind where you don’t move until I tell you to.” His hand came up. One finger under Wes’s chin, tilting his face up. The touch was light and the authority behind it was absolute. “The kind where you don’t come until I say. The kind where you lie there and take what I give you and thank me for every second of it.”
Wes’s breath stuttered. His cock was fully hard now, straining against his zipper, and Nolan hadn’t touched him below the jaw.
“Here’s how tonight works,” Nolan continued. His thumb traced Wes’s lower lip. Slow. Deliberate. A preview. “Two goals — that’s two rewards. Two times I make you feel something you’ll remember tomorrow. Two assists — that’s two times I take you to the edge and hold you there. Plus-three — that’s three times you say thank you before I let you finish.”
“Daddy—”
“I’m not done.” Iron wrapped in velvet. The voice that made Wes’s knees dissolve. “You earned this tonight. Every second of it. And I’m going to give it to you the way you deserve — slowly, thoroughly, until you can’t remember your own name. But you follow the rules. You keep your hands where I put them. You don’t come until I tell you to. And when I ask you a question, you answer. Clear?”
“Yes, sir.”
“Strip.”
Wes stripped. Fast, practiced — shirt over his head, jeans unbuttoned and shoved down, boxers following. He’d learned that when Nolan said strip, efficiency was rewarded and hesitation was not. Every second of delay was a second of pleasure he wasn’t getting.
He stood naked in the living room. Hard, leaking, his cock curved up against his stomach. Nolan was still fully dressed — white shirt, dark slacks, belt buckled, every inch covered. The asymmetry was deliberate. The visual language of authority and vulnerability. I am clothed. You are bare. I am in control of what happens next.
Nolan’s eyes moved down Wes’s body. The same thorough, devastating assessment he brought to game tape — systematic, comprehensive, missing nothing. Wes felt the gaze like a physical thing. Like hands that hadn’t arrived yet but would.
“On the bed,” Nolan said. “On your back. Arms above your head. Wrists crossed.”
Wes went to the bedroom. Lay down on the California king — their bed, the bed where Nolan had called him everything, the bed where they’d said I love you for the first time and every time since. He stretched his arms above his head, crossed his wrists on the pillow, and waited.
The position opened him up completely. Chest exposed, ribs visible with each breath, stomach taut, cock hard and untouched against his abdomen. He was offering. The most explicit kind of trust — here, all of me, do whatever you want.
Nolan appeared in the doorway. Stood there for five seconds, just looking. Five seconds of being studied, cataloged, appreciated with the focused intensity of a man who’d spent his career reading plays and was now reading a body he’d memorized and still found remarkable.
“You’re beautiful,” Nolan said. Not performed — stated. A fact, like a game score. The casual certainty of it made Wes’s cock twitch against his stomach.
Nolan crossed to the bed. Sat on the edge. Still fully dressed, his weight dipping the mattress, and he placed one hand flat on Wes’s sternum. Just held it there. Feeling his heartbeat.
“Fast,” Nolan observed.
“I wonder why.”
“Reward number one.”
He started at Wes’s throat. Open-mouthed, wet, the flat of his tongue tracing the tendon from jaw to collarbone while his hand stayed on Wes’s chest, feeling the heartbeat accelerate under his palm. He found the hollow at the base of Wes’s throat — the spot that made Wes’s breathing change — and sucked. Not gently. Hard enough to leave a mark, hard enough that Wes gasped and his hips lifted off the bed.
“Don’t move.”
Wes’s hips dropped. His hands stayed above his head, wrists crossed, and the effort of holding still while Nolan’s mouth moved down his chest was a full-body exercise in discipline.
Nolan worked his way down with the same patient, methodical attention he brought to everything. Lips to collarbone. Tongue to the flat plane between his pecs. Teeth grazing one nipple — light, testing — and when Wes gasped, Nolan circled it with his tongue, slow and wet, then bit. Not hard. Hard enough. The sharp edge of pleasure that made Wes’s cock jerk and his hands fist above his head.
“That’s it,” Nolan murmured against his skin. “Stay still for me.”
He moved lower. Mouth to ribs, tongue tracing the cut of Wes’s obliques, lips following the trail of dark hair from navel to pelvis. Each kiss was precise, placed with intention, and the path was agonizingly slow — a deliberate avoidance of the one place Wes needed him most.
Nolan’s mouth reached the crease of his hip. The spot where the bruise had been, months ago — the first accidental mark, the grip that had said I want you badly enough to lose control. Nolan kissed it. Pressed his lips there and stayed, breathing hot against the skin, his stubble scraping the sensitive junction of hip and thigh.
Wes was trembling. His cock was inches from Nolan’s mouth — inches, close enough to feel the warmth of his breath — and Nolan wasn’t touching it. Wasn’t looking at it. Was deliberately, maddeningly ignoring it while his mouth worshipped everything around it.
“Daddy, please—”
“Please what?”
“Touch me. I need — God, I need your mouth—”
“You’ll get my mouth. When I decide you’ve earned it.” Nolan’s hand slid from Wes’s sternum down his stomach. Lower. His fingers trailed through the coarse hair at the base of Wes’s cock and Wes’s whole body arched — or tried to, before the command kicked in and he forced himself flat. “Good. You’re learning.”
Nolan’s hand wrapped around him.
The first touch was electric. Firm grip, dry palm, the specific pressure of a hand that knew exactly what it was holding and exactly how to hold it. Nolan stroked once — base to tip, slow, his thumb swiping over the wet head — and the sound Wes made was not a word. It was the place where language dissolved.
“First reward,” Nolan said, and took Wes in his mouth.
Hot. Wet. The devastating suction of a man who had learned over months of study exactly how to dismantle Wesley Kovac from the inside out. Nolan’s tongue flattened against the underside of his cock, pressing against the vein, and his lips sealed and his cheeks hollowed and he took Wes deep enough that the head of his cock hit the back of Nolan’s throat.
Wes’s vision whited out. His hands flew from the pillow — instinct, reaching for Nolan’s head, needing to grip, to hold — and Nolan caught them. One hand, both wrists, pinned back above his head against the pillow.
“What did I say?”
“Hands above — fuck — hands above my head—”
“And?”
“Don’t move until you — oh God — until you tell me—”
“Good boy.”
The words detonated in Wes’s nervous system. Good boy. The key that turned the lock, the phrase that went straight from his ears to his cock, and Nolan knew it — knew the power of it, knew the specific devastation those two syllables caused — and he said it with his lips wet from Wes’s cock and his hand holding Wes’s wrists and the calm authority of a man who owned the moment completely.
He went back down. Slower this time. Long, dragging pulls that built the pressure without breaking the surface. His tongue did something new — swirled around the head on the upstroke, flicked across the slit, tasted the salt that was leaking steadily now. His free hand cupped Wes’s balls, rolling them gently, the dual stimulation — mouth above, hand below — building a wave that Wes could feel cresting.
“I’m close — Daddy, I’m gonna—”
Nolan pulled off. Immediately. The cold air hit Wes’s wet cock and the absence of heat and pressure and suction was a physical blow. Wes whined — actually whined, a sound he’d be embarrassed about later and right now didn’t care about at all.
Edge one.
“Thank you,” Wes gasped. The words came automatically — the trained response, the rule. Three thank-yous before he could finish. “Thank you, Daddy.”
Nolan’s hand stroked his stomach. Soothing. Grounding. The aftercare woven into the scene, the gentleness that lived inside the control. “One.”
His lips brushed Wes’s hip. Soft. The tenderest thing. Then he sat up and unbuttoned his shirt. Slowly. One button at a time, revealing the chest Wes loved — broad, solid, the body of a man who’d spent fifteen years absorbing hits and getting back up. The scar on his knee when he pushed his slacks off. The thick, hard length of his cock when the boxers followed — and Wes’s mouth watered at the sight of it, familiar and devastating, the cock he’d taken inside him more times than he could count and still wanted with an urgency that bordered on pathological.
“Second reward,” Nolan said.
He reached for the lube on the nightstand.
Nolan’s fingers were an education in patience.
One finger first. Slicked, careful, pressing against Wes’s entrance with a steady, unhurried pressure that said I have all night and I intend to use it. Wes exhaled, relaxed, let him in — the trust automatic, the opening a reflex. Nolan’s finger slid inside and Wes’s whole body clenched around it, hot and tight.
“Easy,” Nolan said. His free hand was on Wes’s thigh, holding it open, his thumb stroking the sensitive inner skin. “Breathe.”
Wes breathed. Nolan worked him with one finger — slow, deliberate strokes, curling on the withdrawal, searching for the spot with the same analytical precision he brought to film review. When he found it, Wes’s back bowed off the mattress.
“There,” Nolan said. Not a question. A diagnosis. He pressed again, firm and focused, and the pleasure that radiated from the contact point was blinding — sharp, deep, the kind of pleasure that existed at the border of too much and lived there.
“More,” Wes managed. “Please — more—”
Two fingers. The stretch was fuller, better, and Nolan scissored them slowly, opening him up, his eyes on Wes’s face the entire time. Reading the responses. Adjusting. The film-room look — complete focus, zero waste.
“You take my fingers so well,” Nolan said, and the praise sent a wave of heat through Wes’s body that was indistinguishable from the physical sensation. The words and the touch were the same instrument. “You’re so responsive. So open for me.”
“Sir — I need—”
“What do you need?”
“You. Inside me. Please — I need your cock—”
“Not yet.” Three fingers now, and Wes was writhing — or trying not to writhe, the discipline a war he was losing. Nolan’s fingers worked him open, stroking his prostate with a relentlessness that was either clinical or cruel, and the pleasure was building again, wave on wave, his cock leaking a steady stream onto his stomach.
Nolan’s mouth joined his fingers. Not on Wes’s cock — lower. His tongue traced the stretched rim where his fingers were buried, wet and hot and filthy, and the dual sensation — fingers inside, tongue outside — sent Wes careening toward the edge.
“I’m going to — Daddy, I can’t hold—”
Nolan withdrew. Fingers, tongue, everything. Gone. Wes sobbed — the sound punched out of him, the denial physically painful, his cock throbbing, his hole clenching around nothing.
Edge two.
“Thank you.” The word was wrecked. Gutted. The voice of a man who’d been held at the precipice twice and brought back and was grateful for it in a way that made no rational sense and made perfect emotional sense. “Thank you, Daddy.”
Nolan kissed his forehead. Gentle, tender, the softest thing in a scene built on edges and denial. “Two.” He brushed Wes’s damp hair off his forehead. “One more. You’re doing so well. I’m so proud of you.”
The pride in his voice was the cruelest weapon in his arsenal. Not because it hurt — because it healed. Every time Nolan said I’m proud of you, it landed on the scar tissue left by every authority figure who’d never said it. His father. His coaches. The scouts who’d called him talented but. Nolan said proud and the but disappeared.
Wes trembled. His eyes were wet. Not from pain — from the specific, overwhelming experience of being thoroughly, systematically, devotedly taken apart by someone who loved him enough to make it last.
“I love you,” Wes whispered.
“I love you too.” Nolan positioned himself between Wes’s spread thighs. His cock, slicked and heavy, pressed against Wes’s entrance. He braced on one forearm beside Wes’s head. His other hand found Wes’s jaw, tilting his face up.
“Look at me,” he said.
Wes looked. Gray eyes. Steady hands. The man who’d taught him to see the ice and to see himself. The man who’d fought for him and bled for him and broken his heart and put it back together. The man who called him good and meant it without conditions.
“You earned this,” Nolan said. “Every inch.”
He pushed inside.
Slow. Deliberate. One continuous, unhurried press that opened Wes inch by inch, the thick head of his cock breaching the stretched muscle, the shaft following, filling him in a way that was familiar and overwhelming every single time. Wes’s mouth fell open. His hands gripped the pillow above his head. His legs wrapped around Nolan’s waist and pulled him deeper.
“Oh God — you feel—”
“Tell me.”
“So full. So — you’re so deep — I can feel you everywhere—”
Nolan bottomed out. Buried to the hilt, his hips flush against Wes’s ass, his cock filling Wes completely. They both went still. Breathing. The connection absolute — inside, around, every point of contact alive.
“You’re perfect,” Nolan said. The word was raw. Unedited. The underneath voice, stripped to its foundation. “You’re perfect and you’re mine and I’m never letting go.”
He moved.
The first thrust was slow — a withdrawal that dragged along every nerve ending, followed by a deep, measured push that hit the spot his fingers had found and lit Wes up from the inside. The second was harder. The third harder still. Nolan set a rhythm that built like a game — shift by shift, each stroke adding intensity, the pace increasing by degrees so small that Wes didn’t notice the escalation until he was gasping, his body rocking with each impact, the bed frame tapping the wall.
“Harder,” Wes begged. “Please — harder—”
Nolan gave him harder. Drove into him with the full weight of his body, the solid, powerful thrusts of a man who’d spent his career hitting and being hit and knew exactly how to deploy force. The angle was devastating — every stroke hitting Wes’s prostate with the precision of a targeted play, sending shocks of pleasure that radiated from his core to his fingertips.
“You take me so well,” Nolan growled against Wes’s throat. His hand was on Wes’s hip, gripping, the possessive hold that said mine. “Every time. You were made for this.”
“For you,” Wes gasped. “Made for you — Daddy — I need to come — please—”
“Thank me first.”
“Thank you.” The tears broke. Not from pain, not from denial — from the unbearable fullness of being loved by someone who held you down and held you up simultaneously. Who could be commanding and tender in the same breath. Who said mine with his hands and I love you with his eyes and you earned this with his body. “Thank you, Daddy. Thank you for tonight. Thank you for every night. Thank you for the ice and the film room and the kitchen and the hotel and for not letting me go even when I pushed you away. Thank you for everything.”
“Three.” Nolan’s voice cracked on the number. His composure — the last wall, the final defense — came down entirely. He gathered Wes in his arms, pressed their foreheads together, and his hand found Wes’s cock between their bodies. “Come for me. I want to feel you. I want to feel everything.”
Wes came.
The orgasm was annihilating. Three edges of built-up tension releasing simultaneously, months of love and trust and the specific, devastating intimacy of being known from the inside detonating in a single, shattering wave. His cock pulsed in Nolan’s hand, spilling between them in hot streaks that painted both their stomachs. His muscles clenched around Nolan’s cock in rhythmic contractions that pulled sounds from Nolan’s throat — raw, broken, the sounds of a man losing control because the person he loved was falling apart in his arms and the beauty of it was too much to contain.
Nolan came three thrusts later. Buried deep, his face in Wes’s neck, his body shaking with the force of it. Wes felt him pulse inside — hot, filling, the intimate flood that never stopped being extraordinary. Nolan’s arms tightened around him. His mouth found Wes’s shoulder and pressed there, open and wet and trembling, and the sound he made — Wes’s name, broken into syllables, Wes, Wes, Wes — was the sound of a man who had spent thirty-two years building walls and was letting the last one fall.
They stayed.
Connected. Breathing. Tangled in sweat and come and the specific, irreplaceable warmth of two bodies that fit.
Nolan softened inside him eventually. Withdrew carefully — always carefully, the aftercare as deliberate as the sex — and reached for the warm cloth he’d set on the nightstand before Wes arrived. Because Nolan prepared. Because Nolan thought of everything. Because the man who commanded and controlled and held the line was also the man who put a warm cloth within reach so his partner didn’t have to get cold.
He cleaned Wes’s stomach. His thighs. Between his legs, gentle, thorough, the touch shifting from sexual to caring without losing any of its intimacy. Wes lay boneless, eyes half-closed, his body humming with the aftermath.
“Seven points,” Wes murmured when Nolan lay down beside him.
“Hmm?”
“Two goals, two assists, plus-three. Seven points. What does a seven-point game get me?”
“A shower and eight hours of sleep.”
“Romantic.”
“I bought more cereal.”
Wes laughed. The real one — warm, open, the laugh that filled the apartment and made it a home. He rolled into Nolan, pressed his face against his chest, and breathed him in. Soap, skin, sex, the warm clean scent of the man he loved. The man who was already running his fingers through Wes’s hair with the absent, automatic tenderness of a habit that had become permanent.
“Hey, Daddy?”
“Mm.”
“Best reward yet.”
Nolan’s arm tightened around him. His lips found the top of Wes’s head. “You earned it.”
“I always earn it.”
“Yeah,” Nolan said. The almost-smile was audible — the warmth in his voice, the crack in the wall that was no longer a crack but a door. “You do.”
The apartment was quiet. Their apartment. Their bed. The cereal in the cabinet, the console on the shelf, the two toothbrushes in the bathroom holder standing side by side. The evidence of a life built from wreckage — from a boarding penalty and a film room and the specific, stubborn courage of two men who’d chosen each other over every fear that told them not to.
The penalty was killed. The game was theirs.
Wes fell asleep in Nolan’s arms, and for once — for the first time in twenty-two years — he didn’t ask the universe to let it stay.
He didn’t need to.
It was staying.
Never Miss a Release
Get new release alerts, exclusive bonus content, and reader-only giveaways.