What to Read After Heated Rivalry — 9 MM Hockey Next Reads (2026)

You closed The Long Game, sat with it for a minute, and then did what every Heated Rivalry reader does next: went looking for the book that would do that to you again. The bad news is that Rachel Reid’s specific alchemy — two closeted pros, a decade of hotel rooms, a rivalry that was always a cover story — is rare. The good news is that the individual things that hooked you exist all over the MM shelf, and once you know which thing hooked you, the next read picks itself.

This is the next-reads ladder, sorted by what you came back for. If you want the full mapped comp list instead, start with the complete Books Like Heated Rivalry guide. Otherwise, find your hook below. Trad-pub comps are linked on Amazon; every Fractal Enigma indie title is free with Kindle Unlimited.

If You Came for the Closeted-Pros Secret

The most obvious next read is the one half of readers somehow miss: if you read Heated Rivalry standalone, The Long Game (Rachel Reid) is the second half of the dynamic — the same two captains years later, the careful arrangement finally cracking under one man’s refusal to keep pretending. Read it first if you haven’t. Get The Long Game on Amazon →

After that, the closest indie-KU answer to the closeted-captain architecture is Yes, Captain (Jace Wilder). Eighteen-year veteran captain, the rookie who finally says the word he’d never let himself need, the same slow-burn through the silence a captain has built his whole career on — with the door left open where Reid closes it. Read chapter one free →

If You Came for the Rival-Captains Hostility

If the engine for you was the on-ice rivalry — two captains who have spent years calling each other everything but their names — Enemies in the Penalty Box (Chase Power) is the indie-KU read built on exactly that. Boston’s golden-boy captain, Detroit’s most-penalized villain, three seasons of public hostility, and a league PR stunt that forces them into the same hotel hallways. Closeted-athlete arc, coming out, hurt/comfort, and the heat ceiling taken off entirely. Read it on all retailers →

Want that rivalry energy without the rink? That’s its own next-reads path — see Books Like Heated Rivalry But Not Hockey.

If You Came for the Veteran / Younger-Partner Age Gap

For the late-career-veteran register — an older man carrying his career on muscle memory, seen clearly for the first time by someone much younger — Common Goal (Sarina Bowen) is the trad-pub match: a veteran goalie at the end of the line, the much-younger bartender he isn’t supposed to want, the bi-awakening handled with the patience the trope rewards. Get Common Goal on Amazon →

The indie escalation is Captain’s Pet Brat (Jace Wilder) — a grumpy widower fire captain still wearing his late husband’s ring, a cocky hotshot lieutenant half his age, and the catalog’s most explicit, most dynamically charged read. Same older-man-stops-managing-the-silence DNA, door wide open. Read chapter one free →

If You Came for the Years-Long Pining

If what wrecked you was the duration — a decade of wanting somebody and saying nothing — the trad-pub benchmark is Him (Sarina Bowen & Elle Kennedy): college roommates, four years of shared rooms, the bi awakening that lands after the season ends. Get Him on Amazon →

The indie-KU pick for the quietest, longest-burning version is Cabin Fever Praise (Jace Wilder) — burned-out corporate lawyer, mountain caretaker, a blizzard and one bed and one word that changes everything. The catalog’s most comfortable entry, and the one that makes the slow burn land. Read chapter one free →

The One-Line Version

Read The Long Game first if you haven’t. Then: rivalry → Enemies in the Penalty Box; closeted captain → Yes, Captain; veteran age gap → Common Goal then Captain’s Pet Brat; the long pine → Him then Cabin Fever Praise. If you specifically want the version that runs hotter than Reid ever does, go straight to Spicy Books Like Heated Rivalry.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a Heated Rivalry book three?

The Shane and Ilya arc resolves across Heated Rivalry and The Long Game; the wider Game Changers series continues with other couples in the same hockey world. If you’ve finished both and want the same dynamic with the heat ceiling removed, the indie KU titles above are the closest next step.

What’s the closest book to Heated Rivalry on Kindle Unlimited?

For the closeted-captain architecture, Yes, Captain (Jace Wilder). For the rival-captains hostility, Enemies in the Penalty Box (Chase Power). Both are free with Kindle Unlimited and run hotter on-page than Reid’s trad-pub register.

Are the trad-pub comps on Kindle Unlimited too?

Generally no — The Long Game, Common Goal, and Him are trad-pub releases priced individually on Amazon. The Fractal Enigma indie titles are all free with a KU subscription.

This post contains Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, Fractal Enigma earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Each Fractal Enigma title links to the book page on this site where you can read the first chapter free.

Never miss a release — the newsletter sends new MM hockey titles, bonus chapters, and reader-only giveaways straight to your inbox. 🏒