His Best Friend, Our Bed

MFM Why Choose Romance
by Isla Wilde

Available at all major retailers

Pairing: MFM (Why Choose, No M/M)
Heat: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Inferno
Tropes: Husband’s Best Friend, He Wants to Watch, Why Choose, MFM Ménage, Fifteen Years of Pining, Forced Proximity, Thin Walls, Married Couple, 40-Something Leads, Blue Collar, Competence Kink, Romantic Comedy, Found Family
Length: ~97,000 words

My husband wants to watch. His best friend has wanted me for fifteen years. And our guest-room wall is very, very thin.

Gordon Pike needed ten weeks, a spare room, and zero complications.

Then he moved in with his oldest friend — and me.

I’m Marcy. I’ve been happily, loudly married to Leon for fourteen years. I’ve also known for most of them exactly how Gordon looks at me when he thinks nobody’s paying attention. What I didn’t know was that my husband has been paying attention too. And that the idea of me with the one man he trusts has been keeping him up at night.

So we asked.

Gordon said no. Not to me — to being a one-night party trick for a married couple. He wants a real date. A real place. A real me. Quiet, careful Gordon, who fixes my shower without telling anyone and takes orders from no one once the door is locked.

Now I have a husband who’s discovering that watching isn’t the same as being fine, a best friend who’s finally learning to ask for what he wants, and a house with one bathroom and no secrets left in it.

One date turned into one night. One night turned into the three of us on the living-room floor, deciding nobody’s leaving.

All we have to do is save his hardware store, survive his daughter, and figure out how one woman keeps two men without anybody’s key being borrowed.

His Best Friend, Our Bed is a scorching MFM why choose romance with a married couple, the husband’s best friend, a heroine who keeps them both, no cheating, no M/M, no third-act breakup, and a guaranteed HEA for all three. 🔑🔥

You’ll love this book if you enjoy:

✅ A husband who wants to watch — and a wife who’s nobody’s to hand over
✅ The best friend who’s wanted her for fifteen years and finally asks
✅ One guest room, one bathroom, one very thin wall
✅ MFM where she keeps them both — no M/M, no cheating, nobody’s the spare
✅ Explicit from Chapter One (🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ — graphic, filthy, funny)
✅ 40-something leads with calluses, invoices, and one bad hip
✅ Rotating POV — the wife, the husband, and the best friend
✅ A hardware store to save, a gold-leaf sign to restore, a daughter at the back door
✅ No third-act breakup, HEA guaranteed for all three

Buy Now

Get the Paperback

Get the Bonus Chapter →

⚠️ Content Warning: This novel contains extremely explicit sexual content (graphic MF and MFM scenes throughout, including oral, anal, double penetration, consensual watching, and light restraint; no M/M contact), strong language, consensual non-monogamy that becomes a closed V, jealousy worked through on the page, a past amicable divorce, an adult child learning about a parent’s relationship, money stress, and a past workplace fire (no deaths). Intended for readers 18+.

📖 Read Chapter One Free

Not sure yet? Read the full first chapter right here.

Chapter One: Ten Weeks

GORDON

Everything I owned fit in the bed of a nine-year-old Silverado, with room left over for my dignity if I’d thought to pack any.

Six boxes. Two tool chests. One garment bag holding the suit I got married in and, nineteen years later, got divorced in. Elaine said wearing it to both was the most Gordon thing I’d ever done. She wasn’t being cruel. That’s the trouble with Elaine. She’s almost never wrong and she’s never cruel about it.

I parked at the curb in front of 418 Sycamore Street instead of in the driveway. The driveway was for people who lived there. I’d be staying ten weeks, which isn’t the same thing, and I had a lodging agreement in the glove box to prove it. I’d typed it myself. Dates, terms, a clause about utilities. Leon had signed it with a drawing of a penis and the words witnessed by God.

The plan was simple, and I’m a man who likes a simple plan. Ten weeks in the guest room. Buy the hardware store. Get out. And in the meantime go on not being in love with my best friend’s wife exactly the way I’d been not in love with her for fifteen years: quietly, competently, and from a distance of no less than four feet.

I’d gotten very good at four feet.

The house was a 1924 foursquare, brick to the sills and cedar shake above, with a porch deep enough to hold a swing. The swing hung an inch and a quarter low on the street side. I knew because I’d measured it once when nobody was looking. I’d offered to fix it nine years ago. Leon said it had character. What it had was a chain two links too long.

The front door stood open behind the screen. A radio somewhere upstairs was playing Motown, and the whole house smelled like fresh paint.

She’d promised not to fuss.

I took the first box off the tailgate—KITCHEN, MISC., in my own block capitals, which was a generous label for one skillet and a coffee maker—and carried it up the walk like a man delivering his own subpoena.

Marcy Harlan was on a stepladder at the end of the upstairs hall, barefoot on the third rung, painting the trim around the guest-room door.

I’ll take those in order of offense. Barefoot, on a ladder, which I’d have written a man up for. Third rung, reaching, which is how people end up in my incident reports. And the trim, which on Tuesday had been white and was now going a deep gray-green under a two-inch sash brush she handled the way other people handle a pen.

That’s the order I’d have listed them in if anyone had asked. It isn’t the order I noticed them.

What I noticed was her back.

It was the last Saturday in August and eighty-eight degrees on the second floor. She had on a ribbed tank top that had been white several years ago and a pair of canvas work pants riding low on her hips, crusted at the thighs with every color she’d wiped off her hands since spring. Her hair was twisted up in a clip, dark and coming loose at the nape. The red bandanna was knotted at her left wrist where it always was. And a single line of sweat was making its way down the groove of her spine, slow, between her shoulder blades, past the edge of the tank, down the bare olive strip of her lower back toward the waistband of those pants.

I watched it the whole way.

I was holding a box with a skillet in it and I watched a drop of sweat travel eleven inches down a married woman’s back like it owed me money.

“You’re early,” she said, without turning around.

“You said you weren’t going to fuss.”

“This isn’t fussing. This is trim.”

“It was white on Tuesday.”

“It was landlord white. It was the white of people who’ve stopped trying.” She drew the brush down the casing in one unbroken pull, the line so clean against the plaster it looked taped. It wasn’t taped. She’s never taped anything in her life. “This is called Quiet Fern, which is a stupid name for a good green, and you’re welcome.”

Then she looked over her shoulder.

A decent man would’ve had his eyes on the paint by then. I’ve been a decent man most of my life, and I want it noted that I tried. I was about a second and a half slow. She caught me exactly where I was, which was nowhere near the trim, and she watched me drag my eyes back up to her face, and neither of us said a word while I did it.

Hazel eyes. That one front tooth that sits a few degrees off true and shows when she’s trying not to smile. She was trying not to smile.

“You going to tell me you were checking my cut line, Pike?”

“Your cut line’s fine.”

“That’s not what you were looking at.”

There was a time, any time in the last fifteen years, when I’d have said something about the ladder. I had it ready. Third rung, bare feet, liability.

“No,” I said.

She held my eye a moment longer. Somewhere under us Marvin Gaye was asking what was going on, and I’d have liked to know myself.

“House rule,” she said, and turned back to the casing. “Since you’re a resident now. Honesty.”

“Honesty can be rude.”

“I like rude.” She loaded the brush, tapped it twice on the rim. “Rude I can work with. It’s polite that gets people in trouble.”

She finished the stroke and came down the ladder, and the hall was narrow enough that coming down the ladder put her about eighteen inches from me, which was thirty inches inside my limit. She smelled like mineral spirits and sweat and the orange she’d had for lunch. There was Quiet Fern on her knuckles and a streak of it on her collarbone, and I looked at the box in my arms because the box was safe.

“Sleeves,” she said.

“What?”

“Rolled twice. It’s ninety degrees up here and you’ve got them rolled exactly twice, like always.” She flicked my left cuff with one finger and left a green print on the fold. “Just checking it’s really you.”

She went past me into the guest room. I stood there with her fingerprint drying on my shirt and counted to four before I followed.

It had been her drafting room. I knew that; I’d helped Leon carry the flat file up those stairs the year they bought the place, and I had the back twinge to prove it. The flat file was gone. In its place was an iron bed with a quilt on it, a lamp, a dresser, a desk under the window, and a new brass latch on the inside of the door that still had sawdust on the strike plate.

“It locks,” she said. “Your key’s on the dresser. Nobody comes in here unless you ask them. That’s in your ridiculous contract, I assume.”

“Section four.”

“Of course it is.”

There was a shelf over the desk. One thing on it. A pine box about the size of a shoebox, dovetailed at the corners, with a brass hasp and a scorch mark across one end where the finish had bubbled and gone black.

I knew that box.

I’d carried it out of Harlan Printing fifteen years ago, through four inches of sprinkler water, while a woman I’d known for nine minutes stood on the sidewalk in the smoke telling a fire captain precisely what he could do with his clipboard. I was twenty-eight. I’d been married four years and had a five-year-old at home. I only went on that call because Leon was short a pair of hands and I owed him a Saturday. Somebody yelled that the old man’s brushes were in the back office, and I went and got them, because that’s what I do. I get the thing.

I put the box in her arms. She looked up at me. Soot on her cheek, hair plastered down, furious and scared and trying to say thank you.

That was the nine minutes. Everything since has been the bill.

“I can move that,” Marcy said. She’d seen me see it. She misses nothing; it’s a professional hazard. “It doesn’t do well at the shop. The humidity. But if you want the shelf—”

“Leave it.”

It came out too fast. She tipped her head.

“It’s fine where it is,” I said, slower, and put my skillet down on the dresser, and squared the box to the edge.

Leon arrived the way Leon arrives everywhere, which is audibly.

The van door, the screen door, three pizza boxes hitting the kitchen table, and then his voice coming up the stairwell like it had been fired from something. “Is that a divorced man I smell in my house?”

“It’s the paint,” Marcy called.

“It’s sorrow! It’s sorrow and Old Spice!” He took the stairs two at a time, forty-four years old and built like a bank vault, and he got me in a hug that lifted my heels off the floor. Three slaps on the back. He smelled like wire insulation and the peppermints he ate so he wouldn’t smoke. “Look at you. You look like shit.”

“You look like a mustache someone attached a man to.”

“Twenty-four years.” He held me at arm’s length, delighted. “Twenty-four years of friendship, and that’s your opener. Marce, did you hear that? He prepared that. He rehearsed that in the truck.”

I had rehearsed it in the truck.

“Here.” He dug in his pocket and held something out. A house key, brass, new-cut, hanging from a bent paperclip. “Couldn’t find a key ring. The hardware store’s closed, which if you think about it is your fault. So it’s a paperclip. It’s temporary. You’re temporary. It’s thematic.”

I took it. It weighed nothing. I put it in my shirt pocket and it sat there like it weighed a good deal more.

He passed behind Marcy to get at the last of my boxes and his hand went to her shoulder on the way by. Just the palm, resting, gone. He didn’t look. She didn’t either. It was like watching a man touch a doorframe in his own house in the dark.

“Tour,” Leon said.

“I’ve been in this house four hundred times.”

“As a guest. Now you’re a lodger, per section whatever. Different tour.” He walked me the fourteen feet of hallway like a realtor. “One bathroom. One. End of the hall. We take turns like Europeans. The shower drips, and the handle’s more of a suggestion—you jiggle it left, then pray. Do not fix it.”

“I’m not going to fix it.”

“You’re fixing it right now. I can see you fixing it.”

“It’s a cartridge. It’s a nine-dollar part.”

“Gordon.”

“It’s nine dollars, Leon.”

“He’s been here forty minutes,” Leon told the ceiling. Then he ducked into my room, pulled an outlet tester out of his back pocket—he carries one the way other men carry a comb—and plugged it in under the desk. Two amber lights. “Grounded. I rewired this room myself, so if you die in here, it wasn’t electrical.”

“That’s a comfort.”

“And this”—he straightened up and rapped his knuckles on the wall behind the iron bed, twice, the wall the two bedrooms shared—“is original plaster and lath, nineteen twenty-four, zero insulation, built by men who didn’t believe in privacy. It’s thin.” He grinned at me. That grin’s been getting both of us into things since trade school. “Sorry in advance.”

He meant it as a joke.

I was mostly sure he meant it as a joke.

Out in the hall, Marcy’s brush had stopped moving.

My phone went while I was hauling the second tool chest up the walk. OTIS GARNER, it said, and I set the chest on the porch boards and sat down on the low end of the swing to take it.

“Gordon. This is Otis Garner.”

“I know, Otis. It says so on the screen.”

“Does it. Well.” He cleared his throat, and I settled in. Otis has never in his life approached a point directly. He circles it like a man looking for parking. “I had a visitor at the store this morning. Young fella. Rusk something. Rusk Urban something. Very good shoes.”

I didn’t say anything. The swing creaked on its long chain.

“He wants the corner. He used the word concept four times. I told him I had a man. He asked did my man have financing. I said my man has character.” A pause. “He said character doesn’t close, Gordon. And I didn’t care for him, but I’ve been turning that over since ten o’clock and I can’t find the hole in it.”

“There isn’t one.”

“No. There is not.” I heard him sit; a kitchen chair, by the scrape. “I’m sixty-eight years old. Lorraine’s been gone four years. The store’s been dark nine months and the roof does not care about my feelings. I want it to be you. A Pike buying Pike’s—Lorraine would’ve called that a sign.”

“It’s a coincidence. Horace Pike died in 1958. I’m no relation.”

“So you’ve told me. Eleven times.” He cleared his throat again, and this was the point, finally, coming in to land. “Ten weeks. You bring me a letter from a bank and a plan with numbers in it. Not a love letter. A plan. What it earns, when, and how it keeps earning after the neighbors get tired of being nice. Ten weeks from today, or I sit down with the shoes. I’ve written it on the calendar.”

“The feed-store calendar.”

“It’s a good calendar.”

“Ten weeks,” I said.

“I’m rooting for you, son. I want that understood. But I can’t eat rooting.”

He hung up. I sat there with the phone in my hand and rubbed my thumb across my palm, back and forth, an old habit that has never once solved anything.

Four hundred thousand dollars for the building and the fixtures. Fifty-eight thousand in my account, which was what nineteen years of doing the sensible thing came to once you’d split it down the middle. An appointment at the credit union on Tuesday. And ten weeks on Otis’s calendar, starting today, to match the ten weeks in my glove box.

Two clocks, same length, same start. I’ve never trusted a coincidence that tidy.

Through the screen I could hear the two of them in the kitchen. Plates. Leon saying something. Marcy laughing at it, that low dirty laugh of hers that starts in her chest.

I picked up the tool chest and went in.

We ate at the kitchen table, out of the boxes, because Marcy said the dining room was for taxes and funerals.

Leon talked. That’s the natural order of things. He told a story about a client in Fairmount who’d tried to hang a chandelier from a smoke detector, and he did all the voices, and when he got up for napkins his hand found her shoulder again. And again coming back. I wasn’t trying to keep count. I’d gotten to four by the end of the first pizza.

She’d changed into a clean shirt, one of his by the size of it, and she ate with one foot up in his lap under the table. I couldn’t see it. I didn’t need to. I could see his left arm, and the angle of it, and the slow absent way his shoulder moved while his thumb went back and forth across her ankle. He didn’t know he was doing it. She didn’t know he was doing it. Fourteen years of marriage and they’d worn grooves in each other.

Elaine and I never had grooves. We had a calendar on the refrigerator, color-coded, and we were both very proud of it.

“Thursday,” Leon said, pointing a crust at me. “Trivia. The Lantern. You’re on the team now, it’s not optional. We need somebody who knows things that aren’t wiring or fonts.”

“Typefaces,” Marcy said.

“We need somebody who knows things that aren’t wiring or being corrected.”

“What’s the team called?” I said.

They looked at each other.

“Two Sparks and a Brush,” Marcy said. “Him and Omar, and me. It’s been that for six years.”

“It’s a great name,” Leon said.

“It’s a great name for three people. Now it’s inaccurate.” She licked sauce off her thumb, and there was still a little green on the knuckle, and I looked at the pizza. “We’ll have to vote on a new one.”

“We are not renaming a championship team.”

“We’ve never placed higher than fourth.”

“A storied team.”

I had my fork in my hand. I don’t know why I had a fork; it was pizza. I laid it down beside the box and lined it up with the table edge, and then lined up the knife next to it.

“There it is,” Marcy said.

“There what is.”

“The silverware. You do that when you want to leave a room.”

“I do it when the silverware’s crooked.”

“He’s done it since trade school,” Leon said happily. “Before every exam. Pencils in a row like there was going to be an inspection. I used to move one a quarter inch when he went to the john, just to watch his eye twitch.”

“That was you?”

“For two years, buddy. Two years.”

Marcy laughed, and her foot must have moved in his lap, because Leon’s breath caught for half a second in the middle of his own laugh, and he looked at her, and she looked at him. It wasn’t much. It was two people agreeing on what they’d be doing later.

I got up and did the dishes. There were three plates. I washed them like there were thirty.

When I turned around she was in the doorway to the hall, shoulder against the frame, arms folded, a bottle of beer hanging from two fingers. She stands like that when she’s thinking about something she hasn’t decided to say. I’d seen her do it at her mother’s funeral, and at my daughter’s graduation party, and once in the parking lot of the Lantern nine years ago, when for about a minute I thought she was going to ask me a question I couldn’t have survived answering.

She didn’t ask it then.

“Night, Pike,” she said. “Welcome home.”

“Ten weeks,” I said.

That crooked tooth showed. “Sure.”

At eleven-fifteen I was lying on top of the quilt in my shorts, looking up short-term rentals on my phone.

There was a studio over a vape shop on Canal Street for eleven-fifty a month. First, last, and deposit came to thirty-four hundred and fifty dollars, out of fifty-eight thousand that was already two thousand shy of what the credit union wanted to see. I did the math. I did it again in case it had improved. I closed the app.

Ten weeks. I could do ten weeks. I’d done fifteen years.

I turned off the lamp at eleven-forty. At eleven-forty-six, through the wall behind my head, Marcy laughed.

It wasn’t the kitchen laugh. This one was lower and it had breath in it. Then Leon’s voice, a murmur, no words I could make out, and her again—“Don’t you dare”—and the unmistakable complaint of an old oak bed frame taking two people’s weight at once.

I looked at the ceiling. I’m a maintenance supervisor. I know what’s above a ceiling. I started listing it. Joists, sixteen on center. Blown-in cellulose, which he should’ve put in that damned wall while he was at it—

“Slower.” Her voice, plain as if she were in the room. “No. Slower than that. Make me wait for it.”

The joists were sixteen on center.

“That’s it. That’s—oh, fuck, your mouth—”

Leon had not been joking about the plaster.

I should say what I’d allowed myself, before that night. In fifteen years, not much. A man can go a long while on rules. I never pictured her. That was the main one. If my mind went there I gave it something to do—a punch list, a parts order—and if that failed I thought about Leon’s face, and that always worked. I’d never once let myself wonder what she sounded like.

She sounded like a foreman.

“Two fingers. Now. Curl them—there. Right there. You move from that spot and I’ll kill you.”

She gave directions. Clear ones, in sequence, in the same blunt voice she used to tell a crew where to hang a sign, except shaking at the edges. And between the directions were sounds that weren’t words at all, and Leon’s low laugh, and a wet steady rhythm I was not going to put a name to, and I was hard. I’d been hard since slower. My cock was stiff against my stomach, straining the front of my shorts, and I lay there with both hands flat on the quilt like a man being searched.

Four hundred thousand. Fifteen percent of four hundred is sixty.

“Get up here. I want your cock. I want it now, Leon, I’m not asking.”

Sixty minus fifty-eight—

The bed frame started. Slow at first. A long stroke and a knock against the wall, a foot and a half from my skull, and her voice coming apart on a moan that had my name nowhere in it and went through me anyway.

I gave up.

That’s all it was. No decision. I shoved my shorts down and wrapped my hand around myself, and the relief of it was so sharp I had to shut my eyes. I was leaking already. I spread it down my shaft with my thumb and stroked once, slow, root to head, and on the other side of the wall my best friend’s wife said, “Harder. Come on. Fuck me like you mean it,” and I matched him. God help me. I matched him stroke for stroke.

I told myself I wasn’t picturing it. I was lying. I could see the line of sweat going down her spine, and the green on her collarbone. I pictured her mouth open against a pillow, and her thighs spread, and what her face did when she was close. I didn’t know what her face did. I never had. Fifteen years, and I was learning her from the wrong side of an inch of horsehair plaster, with my fist working my cock and my heels dug into her quilt.

“Don’t stop—don’t stop, I’m right there, I’m—”

Faster now. The headboard was hitting in earnest. My hand was slick and quick, my balls drawn up tight, every muscle in my stomach locked. I turned my head and got my left forearm between my teeth, the meat of it below the elbow, and bit down.

She came loud. A raw rising cry, no words left in it, breaking in the middle. I came with it. It tore up through me so hard my hips left the bed. I spilled hot over my knuckles and across my stomach, pulse after pulse, with my teeth sunk in my own arm so that not one sound would get out of me and into that house.

Then it was quiet.

I lay there. My heart was going like a compressor. There was come cooling on my ribs and a ring of tooth marks rising on my forearm, and the paperclip key was in the pocket of the shirt hanging on the bedpost, right behind her green fingerprint, and I had been a resident of 418 Sycamore Street for nine hours.

On the shelf, in the streetlight, I could just make out the scorched end of her father’s box.

I get the thing, I thought. I don’t take things.

I cleaned up with a T-shirt. I pulled the sheet to my chest. Through the wall they’d gone to murmurs, the easy after-talk of married people, his rumble and her answering hum, and I breathed out and thought, all right. It’s over. Sixty-nine more nights. I’d buy earplugs. I’d buy a white-noise machine. I’d rent the studio over the vape shop and eat the thirty-four fifty.

Then Leon’s voice. Low, but turned toward the wall. Amused, and under the amusement something I hadn’t heard from him once in twenty-four years.

“He can hear you, you know.”

A long silence. I counted nine seconds of it. I didn’t breathe for any of them.

And Marcy, not whispering. Not even trying to.

“Then let him.”

The bed began again.

Want to keep reading? The full novel is available now.

Buy His Best Friend, Our Bed

Get the Paperback

🔥 Want an EXCLUSIVE Bonus Chapter?

The Performance Review — A scene TOO HOT for retailers

The epilogue ends in the front hall, with two rings of keys hitting the dish. This is the rest of that night. Marcy promised her husband and her partner a private performance review — four categories, scored out loud, no arguing with the reviewer. Leon gets marked down for patience. Gordon gets told to stop asking. Then comes the joint assessment. The filthiest night Sycamore Street has had yet.

Get the Bonus Chapter →