Keep It Down Next Door

A Sapphic Neighbors-to-Lovers Romance
by Aurora North

Free with Kindle Unlimited

Pairing: FF (Sapphic)
Heat: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Inferno
Tropes: Ice Queen, Grumpy/Sunshine, Enemies to Lovers, Neighbors to Lovers, Thin Walls, Blackout Forced Proximity, One Warm Bed, Secret Contract Hookup, Age Gap, Caretaking, Keep Quiet

The walls are thin. The complaints are personal.

Mara Coen bought her first condo to prove she’s fine. Loud, bright, and filming everything, the lifestyle creator is thirty days from the brand deal that could save her mortgage — until 4A starts filing noise complaints. Timestamped. Bylaws cited. Delivered at 11:07 p.m.

Eden Varick has built a silent, perfect life no one can wreck. The appellate attorney has labeled bins, blackout curtains, and a partnership vote on the line. Then the new neighbor starts drilling, laughing, and — one very long night — making sounds through their shared bedroom wall that Eden absolutely does not file a complaint about.

When an ice storm knocks out the grid and Mara’s apartment turns dangerously cold, Eden has the only warm room on the fourth floor. One night. One bed. One rule: quiet.

Mara loses.

By morning Eden has a plan: a written agreement, slid under the door at 9:58 p.m. Quiet hours only. No cameras. No sleepovers. No feelings. Term expires January 31.

She’s a very good lawyer. It’s a very bad contract.

You’ll love this book if you enjoy:

✅ An ice queen attorney who melts one clause at a time
✅ A loud, sunshine creator who finally gets to be known instead of watched
✅ Petty neighbor warfare: noise complaints, passive-aggressive notes, and a wall that hears everything
✅ Blackout forced proximity — one warm room, one bed, one very quiet game
✅ A secret contract hookup with terms, breaches, and pink-glitter annotations
✅ Keep-quiet play, praise, control, and an ice queen who learns to ask for what she wants
✅ Age gap (27 × 35), grumpy/sunshine, caretaking, a grovel, and a door that joins two homes
✅ 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Inferno heat — graphic, explicit, and funny
✅ HEA guaranteed

Buy on Amazon

Get the Bonus Chapter →

⚠️ Content Warning: This novel contains explicit sexual content (graphic FF scenes including strap-on play, light restraint, and keep-quiet/control play), strong language, an asthma attack during a power outage, chronic migraines, references to a past emotionally neglectful relationship and volatile parents, and a public online breakup in a character’s past. Intended for readers 18+.

📖 Read Chapter One Free

Not sure yet? Read the full first chapter right here.

Chapter One

Mara

The velvet sofa was stuck in the stairwell, and Mara Coen was going to make that content.

“Okay, so.” She angled her phone up at the landing, where two movers named Luis and Big Luis were wedged on either side of a nine-foot tufted monstrosity the color of a ripe plum. “This is what happens when you fall in love with a couch on Facebook Marketplace and don’t measure the stairwell. Lesson one of homeownership, besties. Measure the stairwell.”

“Lesson two,” Big Luis grunted from somewhere beneath the left armrest, “tip your movers.”

“Lesson two, tip your movers.” She flipped the camera to her own face, did the eyebrow thing, and grinned. “They’re getting pizza. They’re getting a lot of pizza. Luis, do you like pineapple?”

“I like my spine.”

“He likes his spine. We love a man with priorities.” She stopped recording, lowered the phone, and let the grin drop off her face for the first time in four hours. Her cheeks ached. Her lower back ached. The sports bra under her overalls had been damp since roughly ten a.m., and the December air leaking through the stairwell window was turning the sweat on her neck to something clammy and unpleasant.

It didn’t matter. It was hers.

Unit 4B of the Wexford, a 1920s brick building on a quiet Albany street lined with bare maples and wreaths hung by people who owned label makers. Two bedrooms. Original crown molding. Radiators that clanked like a haunted ship. Windows that were technically original and practically sieves. A kitchen with cabinets the color of old teeth that she was going to paint a deep, rude green on camera, in episode four, with a sponsored paint line she did not yet have a contract with.

Thirty days. Thirty days of MaraMakesHome: The Dream Home Transformation, one episode a day, and at the end of it, if the numbers held and she didn’t embarrass anyone, Hearth & Hollow Home Goods was going to sign her to a year-long partnership that would pay her mortgage, her car, her student loans, and the thousand invisible bills that nobody warned you came with being a woman who owned a door.

And if the numbers didn’t hold—

She shoved the thought back where it lived, somewhere behind her sternum, and pushed her sleeves up.

“Okay, boys. Pivot on three.”

“We’ve pivoted,” Luis said. “It’s pivoted. The couch is done pivoting. The couch has decided it lives here now.”

“Nobody lives in a stairwell.”

“Tell the couch.”

It took another eleven minutes, one scraped knuckle, a creative relationship with the laws of physics, and Mara standing on the banister holding the back cushion over her head like a sacrifice, but the sofa went up. It crossed the fourth-floor landing to cheering from exactly three people, one of whom was Mara, and it slid through the door of 4B with a quarter inch to spare.

She kissed the doorframe. She actually kissed it.

Then she went back into the hall to set up the ring light.

The fourth floor had four units. 4A, 4B, 4C, and a narrow utility closet that someone had once, optimistically, labeled 4D. The hallway was long and dim, papered in a faded cream stripe, carpeted in a runner the color of old claret. At the end of it, a tall window looked out over the street, and the light that came through it at three in the afternoon in December was pale gold and thin, like weak tea.

It was perfect. It was absolutely perfect for the opener.

Mara planted the tripod in front of her own door, clipped the light to it, and stepped back to check the frame. Her door, painted a hopeful robin’s-egg blue by the previous owner. The brass 4B with one screw slightly crooked. The hallway stretching behind her, all moody stripes and old wood.

And, just visible over her left shoulder, the door of 4A.

It was black. Not dark blue, not charcoal. Black, glossy, as if it had been painted yesterday. A black door, a brass knocker shaped like a plain ring, and no wreath. No mat. No little ceramic sign that said Welcome or Home Sweet Home or Please Remove Your Shoes. Just a black door, closed so perfectly it looked sealed.

Mara nudged the tripod to the left until 4A was mostly out of frame, then nudged it back, because honestly the black door was doing a lot for the composition. It was ominous. It was cinematic. It looked like the door of someone who owned a letter opener shaped like a dagger and actually used it.

“Okay.” She fluffed her curls, re-clipped them, gave up, and let a few fall around her face. Checked her teeth in the phone screen. Hit record.

“Hi, besties. Welcome to day one.”

She did the whole thing. The keys held up to the lens, jangling. The deep breath. The little break in her voice when she said I bought a home—which wasn’t fake, which was the thing nobody understood about her, that the break in her voice was real every single time and she still knew exactly where to put it. The hand on the doorframe. The promise: thirty days, one episode a day, a whole home transformed on a budget that would make a Pinterest mom weep.

“And I’m not gonna lie to you,” she said, stepping closer to the lens and lowering her voice like a secret. “I’m terrified. I’ve never owned anything bigger than a car, and I’ve never owned a car that didn’t make a noise. So we are going to figure this out together, and we are going to make mistakes, and some of those mistakes are going to be very, very loud—”

Footsteps.

They came from the stairwell end of the hall. Not the heavy mover tread. Something sharper and evenly spaced. Heels, but low ones. Each step landing on the claret runner with the exact same weight as the last.

Mara kept talking. You kept talking. That was rule one of filming in public; the second you stopped, you gave the interruption the scene.

“—and that’s the fun of it, honestly, that’s the whole point, nothing has to be perfect to be beautiful—”

The footsteps stopped directly behind her.

“Excuse me.”

The voice was low. Not loud. It didn’t need to be. It had the flat, finished quality of a gavel that had already come down, and it arrived just at the back of Mara’s neck in a way that made every fine hair there lift.

Mara turned.

The woman standing in the hallway was tall. Not model-tall, but tall enough that Mara, barefoot, had to tip her chin up a few degrees, which she did not enjoy and would not be admitting. She wore a long charcoal wool coat, open, over a white shirt buttoned all the way to the collar and dark trousers with a crease sharp enough to slice bread. Her hair was black and straight and cut precisely at the jaw, not a single strand out of place despite the wind outside. A leather briefcase hung from one hand. A heavy silver ring sat on the index finger of the other.

Her face was all angles and restraint. High cheekbones. A mouth set in a line so neutral it was practically an accusation. And eyes the color of sea glass—a pale, cold gray-green—that took in the tripod, the ring light, the phone, and Mara, in that order, and found all four of them guilty.

“Hi!” Mara said, because her body said it before her brain could weigh in. “Oh my God, hi, you must be—are you 4A? I’m Mara, I’m 4B, I just moved in, obviously, as you can see from the—” She gestured at the hallway. At the boxes stacked by her door. At the ring light, which was pointed, she now realized, almost directly at the black door and currently bathing it in a warm, flattering glow. “—everything.”

The woman’s gaze moved to the phone.

“Is that recording?”

“Oh. Yeah, sorry, it’s—I’m a creator, I do home stuff, renovation, it’s a whole—” Mara reached back and tapped the screen. Stopped it. “There. Paused.”

“Stopped.”

“Stopped, sure, same thing.”

“It isn’t.” The woman shifted the briefcase from one hand to the other. Her nails were short, bare, clean. “Paused preserves the file. Stopped saves it. You’ve captured the door of my home and, if I’m reading the angle correctly, me. I’d like you to delete that recording.”

Mara blinked.

“It’s—you were in it for, like, two seconds.”

“Then it will take you two seconds to delete it.”

“I mean, I’m definitely going to edit you out. I’m not going to post you. I don’t post people without asking, that’s, like, basic—”

“Now, please.” The woman did not raise her voice. If anything she lowered it, and there was something in the way she did it, a slight tightening at the corner of her mouth, that made the hallway feel narrower. “While I watch.”

While I watch.

A small, rogue, extremely unwelcome shiver went down the back of Mara’s thighs.

She cleared her throat. “Okay. Yep. Sure.”

She unclipped the phone from the tripod. The woman stepped closer to see the screen, close enough that Mara caught her scent—cold air, wool, something faintly green and expensive, like crushed cedar and a very clean shirt. Mara opened the camera roll. Found the clip. Four minutes and twelve seconds of her most sincere opener in two years, the break in her voice perfect, the light perfect, the jangle of the keys perfect.

She held her thumb over the trash icon and looked up.

The woman looked back. Unblinking. Patient in the way a glacier was patient.

Mara deleted it.

“And the recently deleted folder,” the woman said.

“Oh, come on.”

“Please.”

Mara made a noise that she would later describe to her best friend as a completely normal adult exhale and which was, in truth, a sound somewhere between a sigh and a whine. She opened Recently Deleted. Selected the clip. Deleted it forever.

“There,” she said, holding the phone up like a kid showing a teacher her empty hands. “Gone. Dead. Sleeping with the fishes. I’m sorry—I genuinely am, I didn’t realize—it’s just the light out here is so good at this time of day and I only have like forty minutes of it and I—” She was talking too fast. She could hear herself talking too fast. “I’m Mara. Did I say that? Mara Coen.”

She held out her hand.

The woman looked at it for a long enough moment that Mara had time to notice the white paint on her own knuckles and the scrape from the banister, a little bead of blood dried dark at the edge.

Then the woman took it.

Her palm was cool. Dry. Her grip was brief, firm, and utterly without flourish, and she let go a fraction of a second sooner than a normal person would have.

“Eden Varick,” she said. “4A.”

Eden. Of course. Of course her name was something biblical and cold. Eden. A garden with a locked gate and an angel at it with a flaming sword.

“Nice to meet you, Eden.”

Eden’s eyes dropped—not far, not for long—to where the strap of Mara’s overalls had slipped off her shoulder sometime during the Great Couch Siege and was hanging loose at her elbow, leaving the sports bra and the curve of her shoulder and a streak of blue painter’s tape she’d forgotten she’d stuck there completely bare.

It was maybe half a second. It was a flick. A glance a person might make at anything.

Then those sea-glass eyes came back up, and they were exactly as cool as before, and Mara decided she’d imagined it.

“The hallway is a common area,” Eden said. “The bylaws require that residents give notice before commercial filming in common areas. Article Six, Section Three.”

“Oh. I didn’t know that.”

“Most people don’t. It’s why I mentioned it.” She stepped around the tripod. Around Mara, giving her a precise, polite berth, the hem of her wool coat not quite brushing Mara’s bare ankle. She fitted a key into the black door. “Welcome to the Wexford, Ms. Coen.”

Then the door opened, and swallowed her, and swung shut.

Mara stood in the hallway with her phone in one hand and a strap hanging off her elbow and the distinct, embarrassing sense that she’d just been served.

She hooked the strap back up over her shoulder. Looked at the ring light, still glowing faithfully at the black door. Looked at her phone.

Forty minutes of light. Thirty-eight now.

“Okay,” she muttered. “Okay. Take two.”

She clipped the phone back on, stepped into frame, and this time she angled the tripod so that 4A was completely, scrupulously out of shot. She hit record, let her face fall into the smile, found the light.

“Hi, besties. Welcome to day one. Before we start, I have to tell you—I just met my new neighbor.”

She widened her eyes at the lens. Let the pause stretch.

“She is stunning. Like, genuinely, you’d die. Cheekbones you could open mail with. And she hates me. I have been here six hours and I have already been read my rights. So if I disappear sometime in the next thirty days, just know it was the glamorous neighbor who hates joy.” She did a little salute. “Pray for me.”

It was good. She knew it was good. It had a hook, a character, a villain. Her audience would eat it up. She was already cutting it together in her head—a little dramatic sting on hates joy, a zoom on her face—when she noticed that the black door of 4A, just out of the frame to her left, was not quite closed.

It was open. Barely. A dark sliver, no wider than a finger.

As Mara watched, it clicked shut.

Very, very quietly.

“She heard you?”

“She heard me.” Mara was flat on her back on the plum sofa, in the middle of a living room that looked like a cardboard box had exploded, her phone on her chest on speaker. The overhead light was a single bare bulb, because the previous owner had taken the fixture, because of course they had. It swung slightly in a draft she couldn’t locate. “Door was cracked. I watched it close. Like a horror movie, Simone. Like a Victorian ghost.”

“Okay, first of all,” said Simone Patel, in the voice she used for sponsors and for Mara, which were the same voice, “why were you talking about your neighbor on camera?”

“Because it was good. It was a bit. Glamorous neighbor who hates joy. It’s a character. People love a character.”

“You can’t post it.”

“I know I can’t post it.”

“Mara.”

“I know.” She pressed the heels of her hands into her eyes until she saw stars. “I’ll cut it. I was always going to cut it. I just—I said it out loud before I thought, and then she was right there, listening, and now I have to live next to a woman who thinks I’m an asshole.”

“You were sort of an asshole.”

“I was a little bit an asshole.”

“You called her joyless on the internet.”

“I called her joyless on my phone. It never touched the internet. It’s in the drafts. It’s in the—” Mara waved a hand at the ceiling. “The purgatory folder.”

Simone sighed. It was a long, deep sigh that had traveled from her apartment in Brooklyn all the way up the Hudson Valley, gathering weight as it came. Mara could picture her perfectly: cross-legged on her bed, laptop on a pillow, reading glasses pushed up into her braids, a mug of the licorice tea she drank because she said it tasted like “something you’d get arrested for in 1890.”

“Look,” Simone said. “I’m going to say this once, gently, and then I’m going to say it again less gently in an email.”

“Oh no.”

“Hearth & Hollow’s brand team got back to me this afternoon. They love the concept. They love the timeline. They want to see the first week of numbers before they send paper, but they’re warm. They’re very warm.”

Mara sat up. The sofa groaned. “Warm like how warm.”

“Warm like, if the thirty days hit the benchmarks we talked about, they’re talking about the full year. Twelve months. Retainer, affiliate, the product line collab, the whole thing.”

Something in Mara’s chest did a slow, painful unclench. She hadn’t realized how tight it had been. She hadn’t realized she’d been holding her breath since the closing.

“Simone.”

“I know.”

“Simone.”

“I know, babe.” A smile in her voice. Then it shifted. “But. And this is the gentle part. Their brand is cozy. Family-friendly. Warm neutrals. Their whole tagline is literally ‘Home is where the calm is.’ They don’t want drama. They don’t want neighbor feuds. They definitely don’t want a clip of their new partner calling a woman in her building joyless going viral on TikTok with a sound bite. And they had legal ask whether your building has any restrictions on commercial content.”

Mara looked at the door. At the brass 4B, backward from this side, one screw still crooked.

“Article Six, Section Three,” she said.

“What?”

“Nothing. There are—there might be some bylaws. About filming in the common areas.”

“Mara.”

“I’ll handle it! I’ll read the bylaws. I’ll give notice. I’ll put a little laminated sign on the elevator. I will be the most delightful neighbor in the history of neighbors. I’ll bake. Do I bake?”

“You don’t bake.”

“I’ll learn to bake. It’ll be content. ‘New homeowner learns to bake for her grumpy neighbor.’ That’s a series. That’s wholesome. Hearth & Hollow would die.”

Simone was quiet for a second. When she spoke again the sponsor voice was gone, and it was just her. Just Simone, who had driven four hours at two in the morning three years ago when Jade posted that video, and who had sat on the floor of Mara’s old studio apartment with her while Mara watched the view count climb and climb on the worst day of her life.

“Are you okay?” Simone asked. “Actually okay. Not camera okay.”

Mara looked around at the boxes. The swinging bulb. The dark windows, rattling faintly in their old frames as the wind came off the street. Her whole life stacked in cardboard, and not a single person in the building who knew her name except a woman who had made her delete her own opener.

“I’m great,” she said. “I own a door.”

“Mara.”

“I’m tired,” she amended. “I’m really tired. I’m happy. Both. It’s a lot of both.”

“Okay.” Simone let it go, which was one of the things Mara loved about her. She knew exactly how far to push and not one inch farther. “Go to bed. Put a podcast on. Don’t drill anything. Don’t film anything. And for the love of God, don’t talk to your neighbor.”

“I won’t.”

“I mean it.”

“I won’t. She doesn’t even want me to exist. I’ll be a ghost. A quiet little ghost.”

“You have never been quiet in your entire life.”

“Goodnight, Simone.”

“Goodnight, homeowner.”

The call ended. The apartment filled with silence like water filling a glass.

Mara hated it immediately.

She’d always hated silence. Growing up in a three-bedroom split-level in Schenectady with two parents, three siblings, a grandmother who narrated her soap operas out loud, and a dog with opinions, there had never been silence unless something was wrong. Silence meant her father had come home in one of his moods. Silence meant her mother was holding her tongue so hard you could hear it creak. Silence was the air before the storm and the hollow after it, and Mara had learned early that the best thing you could do in a silent house was to fill it—make a joke, turn on the TV, sing badly in the kitchen until somebody laughed and the air broke.

She reached for her phone. Opened her podcast app. Scrolled past three true-crime shows, a design podcast, and an audiobook about attachment styles she’d started four times and never finished.

Picked a comedy show where two women argued about reality TV. Hit play. Turned it up to a reasonable level. Then turned it up one more notch.

Better.

She got up and wandered. Kitchen: cabinets the color of old teeth, a gas range older than her mother, a window over the sink that looked straight into the brick wall of the building next door. Bathroom: pink tile, cheerful and deranged. Second bedroom: future office, currently a graveyard for every box labeled MISC.

Primary bedroom.

Her mattress was on the floor. The bed frame—a gorgeous walnut thing with a tall, carved headboard she’d found in an estate sale in Saratoga and paid too much for—was still in pieces, leaning against the far wall in a stack of wood and hardware bags. That was tomorrow’s episode. Day Two: A Bed Fit for a Queen (Who Is Me).

But the mirror. The mirror she could do tonight.

It was the one thing she’d been waiting to hang since she’d signed the papers. A huge, round, antique-gold mirror she’d found at a flea market and had hauled from apartment to apartment for six years without ever having a wall worthy of it. It was going to go over the bed. Right over the headboard. It was going to catch the morning light off the east windows and throw it across the whole room, and it was going to be the first thing she saw every morning and the last thing she saw every night, and it was going to make her feel, every single time she looked at it, like a woman whose life was put together.

She found the hardware bag. Found the stud finder. Found the level. Dragged a dining chair in from the kitchen and set it against the long wall where the bed was going to go, the one that ran along the building’s spine.

The wall she shared, she realized, climbing up onto the chair, with 4A.

She paused, stud finder in hand.

It was a solid-looking wall. Plaster, not drywall. Old. Thick, probably. The Wexford had been built in 1924, when people built walls like they meant them. She knocked on it lightly with a knuckle. It sounded solid. Mostly.

She ran the stud finder along it. Beep. Stud. She marked it with a pencil. Ran it along again. Beep. Another. Measured between them, marked the center, squinted at it, erased it, marked it again two inches to the left.

The podcast hosts were yelling about a man named Brayden who had proposed on a boat. Mara laughed out loud at something, a real laugh, loud and snorting, and it echoed around the empty bedroom and made her feel less alone.

She set the anchor. Picked up the hammer.

Glanced, briefly, at the time on her phone. 9:47 p.m.

That was fine. That was definitely fine. Nine forty-seven was not late. Nine forty-seven was barely night. People hung mirrors at nine forty-seven all the time. That was practically when mirrors were hung.

She lined up the nail and swung.

Bang.

The sound was enormous. It cracked through the room, rang off the empty walls, and seemed to go straight through the plaster, not into it. Mara froze with the hammer in the air.

The podcast women kept talking about Brayden.

Nothing else happened.

She let out a breath. Okay. One more. One more and the nail would be set and she could hang the mirror and go to bed and never make another sound again in her life. She lined up. Swung.

Bang.

Set. The nail was in. She grinned, climbed down, and wrestled the mirror up off the floor—it weighed approximately as much as a golden retriever—and hauled it back up onto the chair with her, arms shaking, curls in her face, bracing it against her hip. She leaned in close to the wall to find the nail with the wire. Close enough that her cheek was almost against the plaster. Close enough to feel the faint chill of it.

And from the other side, three inches from her face, came a knock.

One knock.

Not loud. Not a pound or a bang. A single measured rap of a knuckle against the wall, precise and deliberate, exactly at the height of Mara’s mouth.

Mara went completely still.

The mirror dug into her hip. Her arms trembled. In the gold glass, tipped at an angle against her body, she could see her own reflection—wide eyes, parted lips, a smudge of pencil on her cheekbone. She looked like a woman who’d been caught at something.

She thought of sea-glass eyes. A white collar buttoned to the throat. While I watch.

She waited for another knock.

It didn’t come.

Instead, very faintly, through the plaster, she heard something she’d never have heard if she hadn’t been pressed right up against the wall: the soft creak of a mattress settling. Someone lying back down. Someone who, it occurred to Mara with a slow, prickling heat that started at the base of her throat and spread in every direction she didn’t want it to, slept with her head approximately where Mara’s was about to be.

Mara swallowed.

Very, very carefully, without making a single sound, she hung the mirror on its nail. Climbed down off the chair. Reached for her phone and turned the podcast off.

The silence rushed back in, huge and ringing.

She stood in the middle of her bedroom in the dark and stared at the wall, and at her own shadowed reflection in the gold mirror, and at the invisible woman on the other side of both.

“Sorry,” she whispered.

Nobody answered.

But she could have sworn—she would have sworn on her grandmother’s soap operas and her father’s moods and every broken thing she’d ever fixed on camera—that on the other side of the wall, someone was lying awake, listening to her breathe.

Want to keep reading? The full novel is free with Kindle Unlimited.

Buy Keep It Down Next Door

🔥 Want an EXCLUSIVE Bonus Chapter?

Lights Out — One Year Later — A scene TOO HOT for Amazon

December 19th. One year to the night since the ice storm. At 9:58 p.m., Eden Varick flips every breaker in 4A on purpose, knocks three times on the door in the wall, and makes Mara a thermos of tea. Last year she made Mara be quiet. This year there are no rules, no quiet hours, a new purchase from the tasteful shop on Lark Street — and a confession about what really happened the night of the clink. Told from Eden’s POV.

Get the Bonus Chapter →