The Spare Key

An MM Best Friends to Lovers Romance
by Milo Hart

Shop the ebook · Shop the audiobook

The Spare Key book cover by Milo Hart

Available at all major retailers

Pairing: MM
Heat: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Inferno
Length: ~85,000 words
Tropes: Best Friends to Lovers, Bisexual Awakening, First Time With a Man, Mutual Pining, He Falls First, Blue Collar, Praise Kink, Dirty Talk, Switch, Found Family, Small Town, Earned Grovel

Twelve years. One spare key. And the friend he never let himself want.

Patrick Ellis has always had a key to Simon Brooks’s apartment. He has a favorite mug in Simon’s cupboard, a standing Thursday dinner, and a front-row seat to Simon’s life.

Until the night he lets himself in and finds Simon on the couch with another man’s mouth on his throat.

Simon’s moving away. New job, new city, new man. So Patrick does what he always does: he fixes it. He’s buying a duplex. Simon can take the other half. Same as always. Just closer.

Simon says no. Then he asks for his key back.

Now Patrick can’t stop thinking about Simon’s open shirt, Simon’s flushed mouth, Simon getting dressed up for someone else. And the straight guy who never questioned anything is suddenly questioning everything.

Simon’s loved him for eight years. He’s done waiting. If Patrick wants him, he’ll have to ask: out loud, on purpose, with no building, no history, and no spare key to hide behind.

The Spare Key is a scorching, emotional MM best friends to lovers romance with a bisexual awakening, an experienced best friend who shows the straight guy everything, a duplex with a boiler that has opinions, a lot of praise, very explicit scenes, both men switching, a real grovel, and a guaranteed HEA. Dual POV. Complete standalone.

You’ll love this book if you enjoy:

✅ Best friends of twelve years and a spare key with a dab of green nail polish on it
✅ A water-plant supervisor who fixes everything and the kitchen designer he never let himself want
✅ A bisexual awakening that starts in the first chapter and doesn’t slow down
✅ “I’m not changing my mind. I’m finding it.”
✅ A blue mug, a green velvet couch, and a boiler that’s definitely a Libra
✅ Counting every “anything’s fine” until he finally asks for what he wants
✅ “Ask me again tomorrow when you haven’t just come.”
✅ Best friends to lovers, bi awakening, first time with a man, mutual pining, both men switch, 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ heat, HEA guaranteed


⚠️ Content Warning: This novel contains explicit sexual content (graphic MM scenes including oral sex, rimming, fingering and prostate play, anal sex, sex without condoms after both men disclose negative test results, light restraint by hand, and both leads topping and bottoming; all on-page sex is consensual), a character walking in on his best friend with another man, the end of a relationship (no cheating), a parent’s past heart surgery recalled, the past death of a parent, financial strain, alcohol use, and strong language. No cheating, no violence, no sexual violence. Intended for readers 18+.


📖 Read Chapter One Free

Not sure yet? Read all of Chapter One right here.


Chapter One: Patrick

The text came in at 6:42 p.m., while I was parked on Larch Street with the engine ticking and a bag of Thai food sweating through its paper on the passenger seat.

Offer accepted. Congrats, homeowner. Call me tomorrow re: inspection.

I read it three times. Then I read it a fourth time, out loud, to the pad see ew.

“Offer accepted.”

The pad see ew didn’t say anything. It was Simon’s, with the extra lime he always asked for and never used more than half of, and it was going to be cold in about four minutes if I sat there grinning like a man who’d just been told his test results came back negative.

I’d been carrying that duplex around in my head for six weeks. 114 Alder Avenue. Built in 1924, side-by-side, two units, a shared porch with trim peeling like a sunburn and a boiler the listing described as “original,” which in real estate means bring a priest. I’d walked through it twice. I’d lain awake doing the math on it so many times the numbers had worn grooves. I’d put in an offer two thousand under asking because my sister said if I didn’t negotiate I was a coward, and now I owned—almost owned, would own, pending inspection and a mortgage officer named Brent—half of a hundred-year-old building in the best part of Bellhaven I could afford.

I thumbed open my messages, found Simon at the top where he always was, and typed: Coming up. Big news.

Then I grabbed the bag and got out of the truck.

I didn’t wait for him to answer. I never waited. In eight years of having his spare key on my ring, I couldn’t think of a single time I’d stood on his stoop like a delivery guy. It was Thursday. Thursday was ours. He’d be on the couch with his laptop, frowning at a cabinet elevation, and he’d say you’re late even if I wasn’t, and I’d say you’re welcome and put the food on the coffee table and take the blue mug down from the second shelf, and the evening would happen the way it had happened for ten years.

The front door of 31 Larch stuck in humid weather. I shouldered it, took the stairs two at a time past Mrs. Feeney’s doormat that said GO AWAY in cheerful cursive, and hit the second floor. His door was the one with the brass 2B that hung slightly crooked, because I’d put it back up wrong in 2019 and he’d decided he liked it.

Key in. Turn. The deadbolt gave the soft double clunk it always gave.

“It’s me,” I said, already pushing the door with my hip. “Don’t get up, I know you’re working, but you’re gonna want to hear this, because guess who’s—”

I was humming. I remember that. Some song from the radio, something with a horn section. I remember the hum dying in my throat before the sentence was done, because I’d come around the end of the bookshelf that separated his entryway from his living room, and Simon was on the couch.

He wasn’t working.

He was stretched along the green velvet couch I’d helped him carry up those stairs five years ago, his head tipped back over the arm, and his shirt was open. All the way open. The pale-gray button-down he wore to work, undone to the hem and shoved off one shoulder, and his chest was flushed—actually flushed, a dark pink climbing from his sternum up into his throat. There was a man on top of him. The man’s mouth was on that throat, just under the hinge of Simon’s jaw, working slow and wet, and the man’s hand was down the front of Simon’s jeans, the fly yanked open, his wrist moving.

Simon made a sound. Low. Rough. A sound I had never heard come out of him in twelve years, and I’d heard him make a lot of sounds—laughing so hard he wheezed, swearing at an Ikea drawer, the specific groan he made when the Patriots fumbled inside the twenty.

Not this one.

Then his eyes opened.

They were nearly black in the lamplight. They found me over the other man’s shoulder and stopped there, and for two full seconds nobody moved. I could see his mouth. It was wet. Swollen. Parted like he’d been about to say a name, and the name wasn’t mine.

Two seconds. I counted them later. I counted them a lot.

“Shit,” Simon said. “Shit—Pat—”

The other man lifted his head. He was handsome in the way of men in insurance ads—square jaw, good haircut, stubble that looked scheduled. He looked at Simon, then followed Simon’s stare over his own shoulder, found me standing there holding a bag of Thai food, and—to his credit, to his genuine credit—he laughed.

“Oh, God,” he said. “Hi.”

“Hi,” I said.

He took his hand out of Simon’s jeans. I watched him do it. I didn’t want to watch him do it, and I watched anyway, the way you watch a pipe burst—it’s happening, you can’t stop it, and some part of your brain is calmly noting the pressure.

“You must be Patrick.” He sat up, tugging his own shirt straight. He wiped his palm on his thigh—casually, like it was nothing, like it was any hand—and held it out to me over the back of the couch. “Nathan. We’ve met. Sort of. The Fourth of July thing.”

We had met. I’d shaken his hand at a cookout in July, decided he was fine, and forgotten about him. I hadn’t forgotten about him on purpose. He just hadn’t seemed like a thing I’d need to remember.

I shook his hand. It was the hand. I knew it was the hand. I shook it anyway, because my father raised me to shake a man’s hand, and nobody raised me for this.

“Yeah,” I said. “Hey. Sorry. I—texted.”

“You texted,” Simon repeated. He was sitting up now, doing his shirt back up with fast, furious fingers, and he was doing it wrong. He’d started on the second button. The whole thing hung crooked, one side of the collar higher than the other, a gap at his stomach where the fabric didn’t meet. His fly was still open. I could see the waistband of black briefs and the shape of him under the cotton, hard, unmistakable, and I looked at the ceiling so fast I nearly pulled something in my neck.

“Your fly,” I told the ceiling.

“Thank you, Patrick.” The zip, loud as a chainsaw. “Very helpful. Ten out of ten.”

“I brought food.” I held up the bag. I don’t know why. Evidence, maybe. I had a reason for being here. I wasn’t some guy who just walked into apartments.

Except I was. That was exactly what I was.

Nathan laughed again, easier this time, and leaned over to squeeze Simon’s knee. “It’s fine. It’s honestly fine. It’s a little funny.” He looked at me. “Is that Thai? It smells amazing.”

“There’s—yeah. Pad see ew, drunken noodles, the curry puffs from—” I stopped. I was reading him the menu. “There’s enough. If you want. I always get enough.”

That was true. I’d been buying for two for a decade, and I always over-ordered, because Simon ate like a raccoon after nine p.m., and because some part of me liked leaving leftovers in his fridge. Proof of residence.

“Pat,” Simon said. “You don’t have to—”

“I’m starving,” Nathan said, cheerful, and that was that.


We ate at the coffee table, because that was where we always ate. Nathan sat on the couch with Simon. I sat on the floor with my back against the armchair, which was where I always sat—except normally Simon would be on the couch with his feet tucked under him and nobody’s thigh pressed against his.

I got up and took the blue mug down from the second shelf and filled it with water. Habit. My hands knew his kitchen better than they knew mine—third drawer for forks, the cabinet over the stove for the Advil, the gray hoodie on the hook by the door that had been mine once and was now some kind of public property.

When I came back, Nathan was looking at the mug.

“That’s yours?”

“It’s—” I looked down at it. Chipped handle. A faded lighthouse from a gift shop in Rockport. “I guess.”

“He has a mug,” Nathan said to Simon, smiling, and it wasn’t mean. That was the worst part. Nothing he said was mean. “That’s adorable. I don’t have a mug.”

“You’ve been here eleven times,” Simon said. “Patrick’s been here eleven hundred.”

“Is that a real number?”

“It’s a conservative estimate.”

I ate a curry puff so I wouldn’t have to say anything. Simon’s shirt was still buttoned wrong. Every time he reached for his container the crooked placket gapped, and I could see a stripe of skin at his ribs, and a red mark coming up on the side of his neck where Nathan’s mouth had been. It was going to bruise. He was going to go to work tomorrow, and his clients were going to look at that mark and know exactly what kind of night Simon Brooks had had, and I didn’t know why I was thinking about his clients.

“So,” Nathan said, setting his chopsticks down. “Actually—this is kind of good timing. Since you’re his person.” He glanced at Simon. Simon was very busy with a noodle. “I don’t know if he’s told you.”

“Nate.”

“He’s gonna find out anyway.” Nathan turned to me. “Company’s moving me. Regional ops is consolidating out of Charlotte, and they want me running the Southeast. January.”

“Charlotte,” I said. “North Carolina.”

“The one and only.”

“Congratulations,” I said, because it was the thing you said. “That’s a big job.”

“It’s a huge job. And it’s—” He reached over, picked up Simon’s free hand, and laced their fingers together. “I’ve asked Simon to come with me. Move in. Get a place together. Start over somewhere with winters that actually end.”

There’s a moment at the plant, when a pump trips, before the alarm goes off. A second where you hear the absence of the hum. Everything you’ve stopped noticing, because it never stops, stops.

That.

“Huh,” I said.

Simon finally looked up. He wasn’t looking at Nathan. He was looking at me, the same way he’d looked at me over Nathan’s shoulder ten minutes earlier: steady, dark, unreadable, like he was waiting to see what I’d do with my face.

“There’s more,” he said quietly.

“There’s more?”

“Hearth and Grain is closing the Bellhaven showroom.” He said it the way he’d read off a client’s square footage. Clean, professional. “They told us Monday. End of next month. Everybody’s laid off or transferred, and they’ve offered me the senior designer spot at the Charlotte flagship.”

“Charlotte,” I said again, like it was the only word I had left.

“Charlotte.”

“I mean, come on.” Nathan was grinning, swinging their joined hands. “You have to admit that’s the universe making a point.”

“The universe doesn’t make points,” Simon said. “It makes coincidences, and then people get sentimental about them.”

“See, this is why I love him.” Nathan said it so easily. Like it cost nothing. Like the word was just lying around on the coffee table with the takeout menus. “He’s so bleak.”

I watched Simon not react to love. It was a very good not-reaction. I’d seen him do it for clients who wanted Tuscan tile.

“When do you have to decide?” I asked him.

“December first.”

“That’s three months.”

“It’s three months,” he agreed.

“It’s a no-brainer,” Nathan said. “He’s just being careful. He’s always careful.”

He was always careful. Simon measured twice. Simon read the reviews. Simon had once spent forty minutes in a Home Depot choosing between two identical white paints, and been right—one of them had a gray undertone that went green at four p.m. I’d stood there holding the cart and complaining the whole time. I’d also been there. I was always there. That was the deal. Thursday dinners and moving days and paint chips and 2 a.m. calls about his mother’s blood pressure, ten years of it, twelve years of it, and now some guy with scheduled stubble had his hand down Simon’s pants and a job in North Carolina, and he’d said love like a man ordering coffee.

“Anyway.” Simon set his container down. “You said big news.”

I’d forgotten. That’s how bad it was. For one full second I genuinely could not remember why I’d come.

“Right,” I said. “Yeah. No, it’s—it’s dumb, after all that.”

“It’s not dumb. Tell me.”

So I told him. The duplex. Offer accepted, 6:42 p.m. The boiler, the porch, the two units, closing in October if the inspection didn’t find anything that would make Brent the mortgage officer weep.

“Hey!” Nathan reached across the coffee table and clapped my shoulder. “Homeowner! That’s fantastic, man. Congrats.”

“Thanks.”

“Pat,” Simon said. “That’s huge.”

He meant it. I could tell he meant it, because his voice did the thing it did when he was proud of somebody—went soft at the edges. But he said it to the coffee table. He said it to a pad see ew container with the lime still sitting untouched on the rim. He didn’t look at me when he said it, and Simon always looked at me.

“Yeah,” I said. “It’s pretty huge.”

Nobody said anything. Nathan, sensing the weather, started talking about real estate in Charlotte—how you could get a craftsman with a yard for what a one-bedroom cost in Boston. I nodded in the right places. I finished my noodles. I didn’t taste them.

Around nine I said I had an early shift, which was true, and stood up, and both my knees cracked.

“You’re thirty-eight,” Simon said. “Not eighty.”

It was the first normal thing anyone had said all night, and I almost laughed.

Nathan stood and shook my hand again. Firm, friendly. “Really good to see you, Patrick. Sorry about the—” He tipped his head at the couch, grinning. “Floor show.”

“My fault,” I said. “I should’ve knocked.”

“You have a key,” Nathan said, like it was charming. Like it was one more adorable thing in a list of adorable things—the mug, the key, the man on the floor. “Don’t sweat it.”


Simon walked me to the door.

He always walked me to the door. It was eleven feet from the couch, and he’d been walking me those eleven feet through every version of himself I’d ever known—twenty-five-year-old Simon in glasses he didn’t need, heartbroken Simon in a bathrobe after a guy named Tobias, triumphant Simon in a tie the night he got the Hearth & Grain job. He’d lean on the frame and I’d stand on the landing and we’d say see you Thursday like a liturgy.

He leaned on the frame. His shirt was still buttoned wrong. Up close I could see the mark on his neck better, dark at the center, a faint edge of teeth at one side. His hair was a disaster—the wave he fought every morning had won, flopping down over his forehead, with a dent in it where it had been crushed against the arm of the couch.

He smelled like Nathan’s cologne. Something with cedar in it. Expensive.

“So,” he said.

“So,” I said.

“You could’ve waited.” He kept his voice low; Nathan was clattering containers in the kitchen behind him. “For me to text back.”

My face went hot. “I always—I’ve never had to.”

“I know,” Simon said.

That was all. Two words. But he said them the way you set down something heavy you’ve been carrying a long way, and I didn’t understand them, and I could see him see that I didn’t understand them, and something in his face closed like a door on a slow hinge.

“Night, Pat.”

“Night.” I went down two steps. Turned. “Hey. Si.”

He waited.

“The buttons.” I tapped my own chest. “You started on the second one. The whole thing’s crooked.”

He looked down at himself. Looked back at me. For half a second something tugged at the corner of his mouth that wasn’t quite a smile.

“Goodnight, Patrick,” he said, and shut the door.

The key was still in my hand. I didn’t remember taking it out. It was warm from my fist—a cheap brass copy with a dab of green nail polish on the bow that Simon had painted there years ago so I could find it on my ring in the dark. I stood on the landing and looked at it and heard Nathan laugh at something on the other side of the door, and Simon say something too low to make out, and then I went down the stairs and out into the hot, stupid August night.


I lived, back then, over a dry cleaner on Route 9. One bedroom. Beige carpet, beige walls, a beige refrigerator that hummed in B-flat. Nothing on the walls, because putting things on walls felt like a commitment to a place I was always about to leave. The whole apartment smelled faintly of steam and dry-cleaning solvent, which I’d stopped noticing sometime around 2016.

I lay on my back on the bed for three hours, not sleeping.

I tried. I did the things you do. Turned the fan up. Turned it down. Read a third of an article on my phone about municipal bond ratings. Thought about the duplex, the porch, the boiler, my closing date. Thought about Charlotte, which I’d been to once for a cousin’s wedding and remembered as a lot of glass towers and a humidity that felt like being licked by a large dog.

Thought about Nathan saying I love him across a coffee table full of noodles, easy as pass-the-salt.

And kept thinking about the wrong thing.

Not Charlotte. Not the job. Not Nathan’s jaw or his haircut or his perfectly fine handshake. My brain kept sliding past every single thing it was supposed to be upset about and snagging—like a sleeve on a nail—on two seconds.

Simon’s head tipped back over the arm of the couch.

Simon’s throat, pink.

Simon’s eyes opening and finding mine.

It was the shock, I told myself. You see your best friend—you see anybody—in that state, your brain’s going to replay it. It’s a malfunction. A pressure spike. Same reason you can’t stop thinking about a car wreck you drove past. That was all.

By one a.m. I’d sweated through the sheet and my jaw ached from clenching. I got up and stood in the shower with the water as hot as the building’s ancient heater would give me, which wasn’t very, and pressed my forehead against the tile, and waited for my head to empty.

It didn’t empty.

I was half hard. Had been for a while, honestly—a dull, insistent ache I’d been ignoring the way I ignore a dashboard light. Tension, I figured. Adrenaline with nowhere to go. I’d had a night. A body does stupid things after a night like that.

So I did the practical thing. I wrapped my hand around my cock and decided to get it over with, the way you bleed a radiator—open the valve, let the pressure out, go to bed.

I’m not complicated about this. I have a routine, same as anybody. I closed my eyes and reached for the usual: a woman, a general woman, soft and warm and a little vague around the edges, the kind of picture your brain hands you without being asked. I stroked slow at first, then harder, water sheeting down my stomach, my free hand braced flat on the wall. My cock filled out fast in my fist—thick and heavy, the head slick with water and something more—and I worked it the way I liked, tight on the upstroke, a twist under the crown that made my thighs lock.

It was working. It was fine. My breath was going short and my balls were drawing up tight and the pressure was building low in my gut, good, good, almost—

And the woman wasn’t there anymore.

I don’t know when she left. There was no decision. There was just a picture, all at once, behind my eyelids, sharper than anything I’d ever conjured on purpose. A mouth, wet and red and parted. A flush spreading down a bare chest, over the dip of a sternum, darkening the skin. A long throat arched back over green velvet. An open fly. Black cotton. A hard shape under it, straining.

Dark eyes opening. Finding mine. Holding.

Pat—

I came so hard my knees went.

It tore up out of me with no warning, my hand still moving, my cock jerking in my fist, pulse after pulse of come striping the tile in front of me, and I made a sound I didn’t recognize—a rough, punched-out groan that bounced around that tiny beige bathroom like it was looking for a way out. I had to grab the towel bar to stay on my feet. My whole body shook with it, my stomach clenching over and over, the aftershocks running down the backs of my legs and into my heels.

Then it was over, and I was standing in lukewarm water with my softening cock in my hand, breathing like I’d run four flights of stairs, staring at the mess I’d made on the wall.

I stared at it for a long time.

The water went cold. I didn’t move.

It’s the shock, I told the tile. It’s what was in your head. Your brain grabbed the last thing it saw. That’s how brains work. That’s all that was.

I rinsed the wall. I rinsed it thoroughly. I shut off the water and dried off and put on a clean T-shirt, and I decided—the way you decide to ignore a noise your truck is making—that what had just happened in that shower had not happened.

It didn’t happen. That was settled.


At two-fifteen I was back in bed, still awake, phone glowing in my face.

I didn’t text Simon. I thought about it. I typed Sorry about tonight and deleted it. I typed Charlotte, huh and deleted that one faster. Every version sounded like a man standing on a landing with a key in his hand, and I’d already been that guy once tonight.

So I opened the listing instead.

114 Alder Avenue. I’d looked at those photos so many times the app probably thought I had a problem, which, fair. The sagging porch, shot from a flattering angle. The living room in Unit A, sun-slanted, a radiator painted the color of old butter. The kitchen, which was a crime—1987 oak, a cooktop that looked like it had been assembled in a prison workshop.

Simon would have opinions about that kitchen.

I swiped. Swiped again.

Unit B.

I’d barely paid attention to Unit B. It was the rental side, the half that was supposed to help carry my mortgage. Some tenant, some stranger, somebody with a security deposit and a cat. Two bedrooms. Original built-ins. A window seat in the front room. Hardwood floors under a carpet the inspector would probably need a saw to get out. A front door on the same porch as mine, the two doors maybe eight feet apart.

Eight feet.

I lay there looking at it, and an idea came up through my chest like warm water through a pipe.

Simon didn’t have to go to Charlotte.

He didn’t want Charlotte—I’d seen his face when Nathan said the word. He’d looked like a man reading a contract he was going to sign anyway. He wanted somewhere sane. Somewhere he knew. He was going to need a place if the showroom closed—something affordable, something steady, something with a kitchen he could tear apart and put back the way he liked it. He hated moving. He hated landlords. He hated, specifically and out loud, every landlord he’d ever had.

I’d be a good landlord. I’d be a great landlord. I’d fix things the day they broke. I’d give him a rate nobody in Bellhaven could touch. He could have the window seat and the built-ins and the porch, and every Thursday I’d walk eight feet and knock—knock—and we’d eat on whichever side we felt like, and nobody would have to go anywhere. Nothing would have to change.

It was so obvious I almost laughed out loud in the dark.

I didn’t think about the shower. I didn’t think about a wet mouth, or a pair of dark eyes, or Nathan’s hand moving in the open fly of Simon’s jeans. I’d already decided all that hadn’t happened.

I thought about eight feet of porch.

I could fix this.

It solved everything.


Want to keep reading? The full novel is available now.


🔥 Want an EXCLUSIVE Bonus Chapter?

Row Three — A scene TOO HOT for the bookstore

Moving night at 114 Alder Avenue. The last box is in, everybody’s gone home, the boiler’s ticking at sixty-eight degrees, and Simon has a printed spreadsheet in his back pocket: three rooms, three asks, every status marked open. The kitchen island. The pink tub. The bed behind the green curtains.


More from Milo Hart

Browse all Milo Hart books.

The Married Man Upstairs

The Married Man Upstairs

Milo Hart

The man upstairs is separated. He's just very bad at saying so.

MM Age Gap · Bisexual Awakening · Blue Collar

Never His Son-in-Law

Never His Son-in-Law

Milo Hart

He almost married her. Now he can't stop thinking about her father.

MM Age Gap · Bisexual Awakening · Dirty Talk

My Ex-Husband’s Brother

My Ex-Husband’s Brother

Milo Hart

I was married to his brother. Now I can't stop looking at him.

MM Age Gap · Brother's Ex · Control/Surrender

Separate Rooms

Separate Rooms

Milo Hart

He signed my invoices. Then he signed them away.

MM Age Gap · Bi Awakening · Bisexual Awakening

Not Your Replacement

Not Your Replacement

Milo Hart

He made me come in his truck. Monday, he walked into my archive with my ex's last name.

MM Age Gap · Dirty Talk · Ex's Dad

The Spare Key

The Spare Key

Milo Hart

Twelve years. One spare key. And the friend he never let himself want.

MM Best Friends to Lovers · Bi Awakening · Bisexual Awakening


Never Miss a Release

Get new release alerts, exclusive bonus content, and reader-only giveaways.

Join the Enigma

All Fractal Enigma releases across every pen name. New books, exclusive bonus chapters, reader-only giveaways.

Please wait...

Thank you for sign up!