
The Captain and the Chaos
A Steamy Sapphic Rivals-to-Lovers Hockey Romance
by Kaia Fenwick
Shop the ebook · Shop the audiobook

Available at all major retailers
Pairing: FF (Sapphic)
Heat: 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ Inferno
Tropes: Rivals to Lovers, Teammates to Lovers, Captain/New Signing, Grumpy/Sunshine, Secret Relationship, Forbidden Romance, No-Dating-Teammates Rule, Road-Trip Roommates, Workplace Romance, Competence Kink, Praise Kink, Dirty Talk, Hand Over Mouth, Strap-On, Switch Dynamic, Hockey Romance, Sports Romance, Found Family, Burnout Heroine, Grand Gesture, Standalone, HEA
The captain handles everything. She can’t handle Frankie DeLuca.
Helena Ward has captained the Boston Breakwater for four years, and she handles everything. Leases. Parking passes. Sponsor quotes. Clinics nobody else will cover. A mother in Pittsfield who can’t remember the last time she had to ask. She has one rule for her room, and she wrote it after the last time: teammates don’t date teammates.
Frankie DeLuca is the league’s loudest new signing: a grinning playmaker from a family trattoria in Hamilton who throws no-look passes into empty ice, makes every room laugh on purpose, and turns down the team’s donor gala on day one. Helena covers it. Frankie never asked her to.
They can’t run a single breakout without a fight. So the coach locks them in the video room every day until they learn to talk… and Helena kisses her mid-sentence.
Six terms on the back of a grocery list. Nobody knows. Nothing at the rink. Either of us can end it, no questions. If it touches the room, it’s over. And one Frankie adds herself: Helena eats breakfast.
It touches the room.
Now the captain who has never once said no has to find out what she actually wants, and the woman who makes everyone laugh has to stop joking long enough to say it hurts. Before a championship run makes the call for them.
The Captain and the Chaos is a high-heat sapphic rivals-to-lovers hockey romance with a 7 a.m. breakout drill, a locked skate-sharpening room, an iron headboard, a thirty-dollar church-sale dresser, a lasagna with a secret fourth cheese, a set of terms that ends up framed on the fridge, and a guaranteed HEA. Standalone.
You’ll love this book if you enjoy:
✅ A buttoned-up captain and the chaos-agent new signing who refuses to play the boring pass
✅ A no-dating-teammates rule the captain wrote herself, broken in a video room in week two
✅ “Quiet.” / “Make me.”
✅ Six secret terms on the back of a grocery list (and the day one of them breaks everything)
✅ A locked skate room, a hand over a mouth, and a bite mark hidden under hockey tape
✅ A captain who submits a formal request for oral sex, and a forward who says good girl back
✅ Road-trip roommates, one water stain shaped like Saskatchewan, and a very long shower
✅ A woman who flies home early from Christmas because she can’t stand the thought of her captain eating pie alone over the sink
✅ A strap-on in the nightstand, and a day off where Helena has to say every single thing she wants out loud
✅ A loud Italian-Canadian family who feeds everyone, and a trattoria walk-in where a little girl went to stop being funny
✅ A grovel that starts with a locker-room confession and ends with “Go” in overtime
✅ 🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️🌶️ heat, HEA guaranteed
⚠️ Content Warning: This novel contains explicit sexual content (graphic FF scenes including oral sex, fingering, scissoring, face-sitting, a strap-on, a vibrator during a video call, a hand over the mouth, hands held on a headboard, praise and dirty talk), a secret workplace relationship exposed in front of the team, captain burnout and chronic overwork, a parent’s death in the past and family caretaking, a teammate pushed into a trade years earlier, an emotional breakup, and strong language. Intended for readers 18+.
📖 Read Chapter One Free
Not sure yet? Read all of Chapter One right here.
Chapter One: I’ll Handle It
HELENA
The first problem arrived at 6:40 a.m., while Helena Ward was still on Storrow Drive with the Charles going pewter on her right and a travel mug of coffee sweating, untouched, in the cupholder.
Mica Torres: so sorry to bother you this early!!! landlord says my lease isn’t valid without a guarantor and I have to be out by FRIDAY?? I don’t know anyone in boston. I’m so sorry
She read it at a red light. The phone buzzed again before the light changed, and again on the turn into Brighton, and by the time she nosed the Subaru into her spot at the Breakwater Performance Center there were nine of them stacked on the screen.
Mica’s lease. Katja, stuck at the gate because her parking pass hadn’t been reactivated over the summer. A sponsor wanting a “captain’s quote about the new season, something inspiring?” by noon. Priya, forwarding a players’ association email with can you read this before I lose my mind. Simone: bring the good tape, they gave us the shit tape again. Her mother, asking whether Thanksgiving was at Nathan’s this year or at the house, because Nathan hadn’t said, and Elise hadn’t said, and somebody should probably say.
And Lena Brooks, community partnerships, at 6:51 a.m.:
Morning, Captain! Harborview Foundation donor gala, Sat the 27th, 6–9. Need two players, formal, photos with board members. Have one. Chasing the second. Any chance you can nudge the new signings? Would be HUGE.
Helena turned off the engine and sat for a moment in the quiet.
Then she handled it.
She called the property management company and got a voicemail with hold music that sounded like it had been recorded underwater. She texted player services, then texted Mica: Breathe. I’ll be your guarantor. Send me the form. She texted the security desk a photo of her own pass and Katja’s number and the words she’s ours, please let her in. She wrote the sponsor something about standards and belief and the work nobody sees, which was the kind of sentence that meant nothing and photographed well. She told Priya she’d read the email at lunch. She told Simone she had the good tape. She told her mother she’d call Nathan.
She told Lena she’d see what she could do.
At 7:02 she got out of the car with her bag over her shoulder, her braid tight at the nape of her neck, and nine fewer problems than she’d had at 6:40.
The coffee was cold. She drank it anyway.
Camp day one smelled the way it always did: rubber flooring, fresh tape, the chemical-lemon tang of whatever the cleaning crew used on the benches, and under it the faint, permanent ghost of ten thousand sweaty shifts that no amount of lemon would ever touch.
Helena loved it. She would never have said so out loud.
The room was half full. Returning players drifted in with their summer tans and their summer haircuts, hugging, swearing, comparing which of them had gotten engaged and which had gotten a dog. Katja came in looking murderous and stopped at Helena’s stall long enough to say, “The gate man thought I was a burglar,” and then, after consideration, “A Finnish burglar,” and then left, apparently satisfied that this explained everything.
Simone Baptiste dropped onto the bench beside her and held out her palm without looking.
Helena put two rolls of the good tape in it.
“You’re a saint,” Simone said.
“I’m organized.”
“Same thing, in this building.” Simone tore a strip with her teeth. She’d cut her hair over the summer, close to the scalp, and it made her cheekbones look like something carved. “You look tired.”
“It’s seven in the morning.”
“You looked tired in June. You looked tired at my birthday. You’re going to look tired at my funeral, standing there telling the caterer where the chairs go.”
“Someone has to tell the caterer.”
“See, that’s the problem with you.” Simone bent to her laces. “You think that’s a joke.”
Helena didn’t answer that, because her phone buzzed—Mica, the guarantor form, seven pages—and because the door swung open on a burst of noise and the room’s attention went with it.
Frankie DeLuca did not walk into rooms. She arrived in them.
She was laughing before she cleared the frame, half-turned to say something over her shoulder to Dougie, the head equipment manager—Dougie, who had not smiled at a player since the Obama administration—and Dougie was grinning. Grinning, and carrying her bag.
“—swear to God, if you get my hollow right on the first try I’ll name my firstborn after you,” she was saying. “Doug DeLuca. It’s got a ring.”
“You’ll get a three-quarter and like it,” Dougie said, and he was still grinning when he set the bag down at the empty stall two down from Helena’s.
Helena saw her body first. She would think about that later, with a kind of furious embarrassment: that she’d registered the shoulders under the jacket, the strong line of a skater’s thighs in black jeans, the way she moved, loose and fast and absolutely certain of where she was in space, before she’d so much as looked at her face.
Then she looked at the face, and that was worse.
Short dark curls, deliberately messy. Brown eyes, very bright. Eyebrows that seemed to be having their own separate conversation. A wide mouth with a gap between the front teeth, the kind of grin that should have looked goofy and instead looked like an invitation to something you’d regret in the morning.
The jacket was suede. Rust-colored, seventies collar, fringe on the back yoke. It should have been ridiculous. On her it looked like she’d been born in it, in a motel somewhere outside Tucson, to a mother who’d been a rodeo queen.
“Morning, Boston,” Frankie said to the room, and the room—Helena’s room, which had taken two full seasons to warm up to Simone—said morning back.
Helena looked down at the guarantor form. Page three. Relationship to applicant.
She wrote Teammate in very neat block capitals and pressed so hard the pen tore the paper.
Mara Sullivan gave her camp speech standing, as she always did, arms folded, a whiteboard behind her that she never used.
“Last season,” Mara said, “we were the best defensive team in this league.”
A murmur. A couple of sticks tapped the floor.
“Don’t clap. It’s not a compliment. We were the best defensive team in this league, and we went out in the first round, because we couldn’t score on a Sunday-morning beer-league goalie who’d been out until four.” Mara let that sit. Mara was forty-seven and had played eleven years of pro hockey before most of the room had owned skates, and she had the stillness of a woman who no longer needed anyone to like her. “We’re done winning two-one and praying. This year we move the puck. We carry it in instead of dumping it and chasing. We use the right side of the ice like it belongs to us. We take risks that make sense, and when they don’t work, we support them instead of standing around looking betrayed.”
Her eyes moved across the room and landed, briefly, on Frankie, who was sprawled in her stall with her ankles crossed like she was at a cookout.
“Some of you are going to hate it,” Mara said. “Hate it in October. In April I’ll buy you a drink.”
That was the whole speech. Mara never went long. She nodded once at Helena—yours—and left.
Helena stood up.
She’d done this four years running. Rookies on the left, new signings on the right, returning players pretending not to listen and listening anyway. She didn’t need notes.
“Welcome,” she said. “For the new faces, I’m Helena. I wear the C. Mostly that means if you have a problem, it’s my problem, and if you’re the problem, it’s also my problem, so let’s try for the first one.”
A ripple of laughter. Mica, in the rookie row, looked at her like she’d personally invented hockey.
“Standards. You’re on the ice ten minutes before the coaches are, every day. Not because Mara checks. Because I do.” She let her eyes move. “Recovery is part of the job. If the trainers tell you to sleep, you sleep. If they tell you to eat, you eat. I don’t care if you’re in a fight with your girlfriend or your landlord or God. You eat.”
“Says the woman who had cold coffee for breakfast,” Simone murmured, not quite quietly enough.
Helena ignored her. “The media staff will brief you on interviews. Say less than you think you should. Say nothing about anybody in this room you wouldn’t say to her face.” She paused. “And the last thing.”
She’d said it every September for four years. It never got easier, and she’d never let that show.
“Nobody dates inside this room.”
The returning players had heard it before. A few of them glanced at the floor.
“I don’t care who you see outside this building. That’s your life. But inside this room—teammates, no. We’ve done it the other way. We know how it ends.” She kept her voice level. “It ends with half the room picking a side and the other half pretending they didn’t, and all of us losing in April. So: no. Not a guideline. Not a suggestion. A rule.”
The silence after that was the kind she’d come to expect. Respectful. A little heavy.
Then, from two stalls down, a voice like a grin:
“Quick question, Captain.”
Helena turned her head.
Frankie hadn’t uncrossed her ankles. She had one hand raised, polite as a schoolgirl, and the eyebrows were up.
“Is that a ‘no peeing in the pool’ rule,” Frankie asked, “or a ‘no peeing in the pool unless nobody’s looking’ rule?”
The room cracked open. Priya actually snorted. Katja, who almost never laughed, made a sound like a kettle. Even Simone’s shoulders were shaking.
Helena waited for it to settle. She was aware of her own face holding perfectly still, the way it did in a penalty kill with forty seconds left: no expression, no information, nothing for anyone to read.
“It’s a ‘nobody pees in the pool’ rule, DeLuca,” she said. “The rest of us swim here.”
Another laugh, warmer, on her side this time. Frankie’s grin widened, like she’d been hoping Helena would hit back and was delighted to be right.
“Copy that,” Frankie said. “Dry pool. Got it.”
It should have been nothing. Camp-day banter. Helena had absorbed a hundred jokes worse than that one.
But as the laughter thinned, she let her eyes move once around the room the way she always did, checking, counting, and they stopped on Brooke Hadley.
Brooke was in her stall near the door, taping her stick. Thirty-one, square-jawed, a third-liner who’d won more puck battles for this team than anybody would ever write about. She’d been here longer than Helena had worn the C.
She wasn’t laughing.
She was looking at the tape in her hands, winding it on with slow, exact turns, toe to heel, and her mouth was a flat line.
Helena knew exactly what that line meant. She’d put it there.
She turned back to the room. “Ice in forty,” she said, and sat down, and opened Mica’s guarantor form to page four.
The first skate of camp was always about the same thing: who’d done their summer homework and who’d spent it at the lake.
Helena had done hers. She always did. Six a.m. sessions at a rink in Pittsfield where the Zamboni driver had known her since she was nine; gap-control drills until her hips burned; a strength coach in Somerville who called her the cathedral because, he said, she was built to hold up a roof. She moved through the warm-up with the old familiar pleasure of a body that did what it was told.
Then they went to one-on-ones, and she drew Frankie DeLuca.
“Captain,” Frankie said, gliding up to the far blue line, stick on her knees. In gear she looked bigger, harder, the curls crammed under the helmet, the grin still visible through the cage. “Be gentle with me. I’m new.”
“No,” Helena said.
The whistle went.
Frankie came at her with speed and no hurry at all, which was a combination Helena had seen maybe five times in her career. The puck lived on her blade like it had been glued there. Helena backed off, matching her, gap tight, stick in the lane—this was the oldest dance in hockey and Helena knew every step of it—and Frankie dropped her right shoulder like she was going wide.
Helena didn’t bite. She’d seen the shoulder on video. She’d been ready for it.
So Frankie didn’t go wide. She stopped. Dead stop, ice spraying, and pulled the puck back through her own skates and then—impossibly, stupidly, beautifully—through Helena’s, five-hole on a defender, and was past her and in alone, and lifted it over the goalie’s blocker with a flick so small it barely counted as a shot.
The bench went nuts. Somebody banged a stick on the boards.
Helena turned and skated back to the line. Her ears were hot under the helmet.
“Sorry,” Frankie said, coasting by. She did not sound sorry at all. “Habit.”
“Again,” Helena said.
The second time, she didn’t watch the shoulder or the hands. She watched Frankie’s hips, the way she’d been taught at nineteen by a coach who’d said everything lies except the belly button. When Frankie stopped, Helena stopped with her. When she pulled the puck back, Helena’s stick was already there. She took Frankie into the boards hard enough to rattle the glass—legal, clean, puck-first—and felt Frankie’s body go solid against hers for one full second, felt the heat of her through two layers of gear, heard her breath leave her in a startled huh.
The puck squirted free. Helena chipped it up the wall.
Frankie, pinned against the boards, turned her head inside the cage and looked at her from four inches away. Up close her eyes were browner than Helena had thought, with gold at the edges, and they were bright with something that wasn’t anger.
“Okay,” Frankie said, a little breathless. “There she is.”
Helena pushed off and skated away and did not look back. She was aware of her pulse in her throat, under the neck guard. She was aware that she’d enjoyed that more than she’d enjoyed anything since spring.
She put that away, the way she put everything away, and lined up for the next rep.
Lena Brooks found her outside the trainers’ room after practice, which was where Lena always found her: in the gap between one obligation and the next, where Helena was most likely to say yes.
“Got a sec, Captain?”
Helena’s hair was wet from the shower and she had an ice pack strapped to her left hip and Mica’s guarantor form, all seven signed pages of it, folded in her back pocket. “One,” she said.
Lena was thirty-five and permanently underslept, with a lanyard full of keycards and a phone she held the way some people held a cigarette. She wasn’t a bad person. She was a woman with one and a half staff members and a calendar full of things the front office had promised people without telling her first.
“So, the gala,” Lena said.
“I saw your text.”
“Right. So. I’ve got Priya. And I asked the new signings, like you—like I said I would—and Torres has the youth clinic in Worcester that day, and Ellis’s sister is getting married, and DeLuca.” She breathed out. “DeLuca declined.”
“Declined.”
“Said it’s optional.” Lena held up both hands. “Which it is. It is optional. I’m not saying it isn’t. She was perfectly nice about it. She was weirdly nice about it, actually, she asked me where I got my boots. But it’s the board, Helena. It’s the Harborview board. They’ve funded half the girls’ programs in Dorchester and they want to meet the new star, and I can’t give them Priya and an empty chair.”
Helena knew what she was supposed to say next. She’d known since the word declined.
She thought, briefly and with great specificity, about her Saturday. The last Saturday before the preseason schedule ate her alive. She’d planned it the way some women planned weddings: Esplanade at six, coffee she’d actually drink hot, the dresser she’d been stripping on the balcony since July, a paperback about a seventeenth-century apothecary who solved murders. A bath. Bed by nine. Nobody’s problem but her own.
She thought about the Harborview board, and the girls’ programs in Dorchester, and Lena’s face.
“I’ll handle it,” Helena said.
Lena blinked. “You’ll—talk to her?”
“No. I’ll go.”
“You’d go? Helena, that’s your off Saturday, I know it’s your—”
“It’s fine.” It wasn’t. It was easier. It was always easier. “Send me the details. What do they want, speech or just photos?”
“Just photos. Maybe a few words at the donor table. God. You’re a lifesaver.” Lena was already typing, already moving on to the next fire, the relief rolling off her in waves. “Seriously, I owe you. I owe you like five.”
“You don’t owe me anything.”
“I’m going to put that on your tombstone,” Lena said, and was gone.
Helena stood in the hall with the ice pack going slowly numb against her hip.
Weirdly nice about it. Of course she’d been. Frankie DeLuca had probably said no to Lena the way she’d come through that door this morning—laughing, easy, charming the furniture—and walked away without a backward glance, and never once wondered who would end up in the chair.
It didn’t matter. It was done. It was handled.
She went to find her bag.
The hallway outside the dressing room was long and windowless, painted the particular institutional blue of every hockey building in North America, lined with framed photos of seasons nobody remembered. At this hour it was nearly empty. Somewhere a skate sharpener whined.
Frankie DeLuca was leaning against the wall beside the exit, one sneaker flat against the paint, scrolling her phone.
She’d changed back into the jeans and the suede jacket. Her curls were damp and darker for it, and she smelled—Helena registered this before she could stop herself—like whatever cheap drugstore shampoo they stocked in the showers, and under it something warmer. Orange peel. Clove.
Helena kept walking.
“Heard you’re covering my gala,” Frankie said, without looking up.
Helena stopped.
She hadn’t told anyone. She’d agreed eleven minutes ago, in an empty hallway. Lena must have texted someone, who’d texted someone, the way everything in this building traveled at the speed of light except actual answers.
“Lena needed a second player,” Helena said. “So she has one.”
Now Frankie looked up. Lazily. All the way up, from Helena’s sneakers to her damp braid, taking her time about it, the way you’d read a menu in a restaurant you were thinking about coming back to. When she got to Helena’s eyes, she held them.
“You didn’t have to,” Frankie said.
“Someone did.”
“Did they?” Frankie pushed off the wall. Not toward Helena, exactly. Just—into the hallway, into the space, so that suddenly there was less of it. She was three inches shorter, and she did not seem to know or care. “It’s optional. It says it on the email. It says it in my contract. Optional. From the Latin, meaning, ‘you can say no and the building won’t fall down.'”
“That’s not what the Latin means.”
“It’s what it means to me.” The grin flickered—there and gone, a light switched on and off to see if anyone was home. “I’ve done every appearance I signed up for. I’ll do every one this season, and I’ll smile in all the pictures, and I’ll hold all the babies. I’m great with babies. Babies love me.”
“I’m sure.”
“But that Saturday I’m busy.” Frankie tilted her head. Her eyes were very steady. “And instead of letting Lena find somebody who actually wanted to go, or telling the board that a new signing had a prior commitment like an adult human being, you jumped in front of it. Before anybody asked you.”
“Lena asked me.”
“Lena asked you if you’d nudge me. I know, because she told me she was going to.” Frankie’s voice didn’t rise. If anything it went softer, which was worse. “You didn’t nudge me. You didn’t even come find me. You just decided I was a problem, and you made the problem disappear, and now everybody in that room thinks you’re a hero and I’m the diva who ditched the orphans.”
“There aren’t any orphans.”
“Figure of speech, Captain. Keep up.”
Helena felt it happen—the old instinct, the one that had kept her alive through four seasons of other people’s crises. Smooth it. Lower the temperature. Say the reasonable thing and walk away clean.
“It’s done,” she said. “It’s not a big deal. I don’t mind.”
Frankie studied her.
Then she laughed—short, low, not the big room-filling laugh from this morning. Something quieter, with an edge on it.
“See, I think you do mind,” Frankie said. “I think you mind a lot. I think you had plans that Saturday, and you gave them up so fast you didn’t even feel it go, and now you’re going to stand there in a dress you hate, being gracious at a bunch of rich people, and think about how I’m a selfish brat the whole time.” She shrugged. “Which is fine. Think whatever you want. But don’t do it for me. I didn’t need covering. I didn’t ask you.”
“Someone had to,” Helena said again, and heard how it sounded.
Frankie stepped past her toward the exit. As she went by, close enough that Helena felt the brush of suede against her bare forearm, she paused—just for a heartbeat—and said, low, almost kind:
“No, Captain. Nobody did.”
Then she shouldered through the door and was gone, and the hallway was long and blue and empty again, and the skate sharpener had stopped.
Helena stood there.
She’d been called worse things than a hero. She’d been called a cold bitch and a company woman and, once, memorably, by a Toronto forward, a walking parking ticket. She’d been told by the woman she’d loved for six years that she turned every need into a task. None of it had touched her. She’d made very sure, over a very long time, that nothing did.
She looked down.
Her hands were shaking.
Not much. A fine tremor, the kind she got after a hard kill, after the adrenaline had nowhere left to go. She curled them into fists at her sides and waited for it to stop, and it didn’t, and she understood with a slow, cold, sinking clarity that it wasn’t anger.
It wasn’t anger at all.
Want to keep reading? The full novel is available now.
🔥 Want an EXCLUSIVE Bonus Chapter?
Term Eight — A scene TOO HOT for the bookstore
One year later. Preseason in Ottawa, the same hotel on the Rideau Canal, the same water stain shaped like Saskatchewan, and two beds they only need one of. A roll of the good tape, a safe word everybody on the team already knows, and Helena’s point of view. This time the captain calls the play.
More from Kaia Fenwick
Browse all Kaia Fenwick books.

The Captain and the Chaos
The captain handles everything. She can't handle Frankie DeLuca.

Doubles or Nothing
She said doubles was for losers. Then she met the woman who'd make her beg for a second set.

She Calls the Play
She's never let anyone run her offense. The six-foot-five center across the hall isn't asking.

The Partner Clause
Twelve clauses. One season. Clause Nine says no.

The Trade We Made
She traded me once. Now we're on the same line. And the coach has one rule.
Never Miss a Release
Get new release alerts, exclusive bonus content, and reader-only giveaways.
